Is paid editorial evil? Last of a series.
Part one of this series examined the seeming scarcity of advertorial -- that is, paid editorial content -- and asked if the online media buyer was partially to blame. This week, some myth-busting insight from publishers and online media buyers.
Myth 1: Publishers Think Advertorial Is Evil
Though some publishers still don't, or won't, sell advertorial, generally most will when the proposition fits their Web site's content and audience. In fact, many publishers demonstrate their best creativity when it comes to generating advertorial opportunities.
NATIONALGEOGRAPHIC.COM, which has embraced advertorial since the Web's early days, has entire microsites of paid content. Its EarthPulse campaign for GE is just one example. "Advertorial isn't bad as long as it sticks to the mission of the site," observes Ted Ryan of NATIONALGEOGRAPHIC.COM. "The trick is in finding convergence of relevancy, user experience, brand legitimacy, and site stickiness."
The washingtonpost.com Viewpoint, the paid version of its popular Live Online real-time chats, takes advantage of the Web through user interaction. At Viewpoint, hosted during the workday and clearly billed as paid time, paying guests field questions (sometimes negative ones) from users. Successful user participation, despite the fact the time is paid for, demonstrates the intrinsic value for both parties.
Myth 2: Advertorial Opportunities Are Scarce
Publishers say we see so little advertorial because not a lot of advertisers request it. But publishers also don't create advertorial opportunities then find advertisers for it.
Publishers don't necessarily flaunt their advertorial opportunities. Media kits are often devoid of the word "advertorial." Some may not include any mention of it, even when the publisher sells it. Most ad networks don't sell advertorial, which also reduces demand. If you want to buy advertorial, be ready to ask for it.
Myth 3: Online Media Buyers Are to Blame for Scarcity
No fingers have been pointed, but it does seem most advertorial buy requests have been advertiser-direct, until recently. Ryan notes only in the last nine months have there been more requests from agencies than from clients directly. He attributes this to both the resurgence of the online advertising market and the online migration of traditional advertising dollars. Noteworthy is NATIONALGEOGRAPHIC.COM has no Internet pure-plays participating in its advertorial programs.
Myth 4: Advertorial Is More Complex Than Other Online Advertising
Although advertorial buys aren't typically as simple as purchasing a package of impressions for standard units, the perception of advertorial as more complex isn't wholly accurate. It's all in how the media buyer, creative team, and publisher approach it. Case in point: SpecificMEDIA purchased standard ClickZ ad space (to the right of this column) and uses it as an advertorial-style play.
Advertorial nevertheless requires more than a media buyer and graphic designer. Most advertorial creative relies on solid copywriting and content that's the antithesis of a hard sell. Advertorial can become complex if the publisher must build out separate Web pages to accommodate it.
Tom Hernandez of SpecificMEDIA feels advertorial complexity may be a hindering factor. "You have to select a topic that will appeal to the intended audience and provide real value, and then marshal the resources to complete the project."
Myth 5: Advertorial Performs Better Than Banners
Very few people discuss advertorial in the context of performance. Instead, they view advertorial as more about enhancing user experience and information levels.
"Advertorial is neither about branding nor direct response," comments Eric Easter of washingtonpost.com. "It's about an option to get out more information than the existing online ad opportunities offer."
"We don't even talk about click-through rates or impressions of our advertorials," said Tammy Harrison of BlueSuitMom.com/BSM Media. "Those results are not as significant in the big picture."
Media buyer Shea Park believes advertorial improves campaign performance: "It delivers a more informed customer who's more committed to taking an action."
"My experience tells me that paid job postings and event listings are of just as much interest to our readers as is our editorial," responded Ken Schafer of One Degree. "So far, neither side has complained."
Sounds like advertorial deserves more attention than it's received from media buyers so far. Let's build more demand.
Vote for your favorite products, services, and campaigns! The ClickZ Marketing Excellence Awards recognize ClickZ readers choices for achievement and innovation in online marketing technology, solutions, and execution. Voting runs until Wednesday, June 22 (EOB, EST).
On the heels of a fantastic event in New York City, ClickZ Live is taking the fun and learning to Toronto, June 23-25. With over 15 years' experience delivering industry-leading events, ClickZ Live offers an action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covering all aspects of digital marketing. Register today!
Want to learn more? Join us at ClickZ Live San Francisco, Aug 10-12!
Educating marketers for over 15 years, ClickZ Live brings together industry thought leaders from the largest brands and agencies to deliver the most advanced, educational digital marketing agenda. Register today and save $500!
A highly driven subject matter expert with a thirst for knowledge, an unbridled sense of curiosity, and a passion to deliver unbiased, simplified information and advice so businesses can make better decisions about how to spend their dollars and resources, multiple award-winning entrepreneur Hollis Thomases (@hollisthomases) is a sole practitioner and digital ad/marketing "gatekeeper." Her 16 years working in, analyzing, and writing about the digital industry make Hollis uniquely qualified to navigate the fast-changing digital landscape. Her client experience includes such verticals as Travel/Tourism/Destination Marketing, Retail & Consumer Brands, Health & Wellness, Hi-Tech, and Higher Education. In 1998, Hollis Thomases founded her first company, Web Ad.vantage, a provider of strategic digital marketing and advertising service solutions for such companies as Nokia USA, Nature Made Vitamins, Johns Hopkins University, ENDO Pharmaceuticals, and Visit Baltimore. Hollis has been an regular expert columnist with Inc.com, and ClickZ and authored the book Twitter Marketing: An Hour a Day, published by John Wiley & Sons. Hollis also frequently speaks at industry conferences and association events.
Gartner Magic Quadrant for Digital Commerce
This Magic Quadrant examines leading digital commerce platforms that enable organizations to build digital commerce sites. These commerce platforms facilitate purchasing transactions over the Web, and support the creation and continuing development of an online relationship with a consumer.
Paid Search in the Mobile Era
Google reports that paid search ads are currently driving 40+ million calls per month. Cost per click is increasing, paid search budgets are growing, and mobile continues to dominate. It's time to revamp old search strategies, reimagine stale best practices, and add new layers data to your analytics.
June 10, 2015
12:00pm ET/9:00am PT