See how one company tries to grow its list using an e-mail change-of-address and append service and negative option-opt-out, but fails at connecting with quality customers.
E-mail list attrition is a problem; no one wants to see the size of their e-mail audience decrease or even stay stable. Everyone wants growth.
MarketingSherpa recently reported that while 67 percent of marketers are seeing their list sizes increase, the other 33 percent have list quantities that are stable or declining. Of those with declining lists, the average change in list size in the first half of 2009 was more than 10 percent; consumer lists decreased an average of 6 percent, while business lists had a decrease of more than double that (13 percent).
One way to attack declining list sizes is by using an e-mail change-of-address or append service. A number of companies will take your list and either provide updated e-mail addresses for these contacts or find an e-mail address for records that don't currently include one. These services can be useful, but they also have drawbacks, especially when marketers take liberties with how they use them.
Exhibit A: an e-mail I recently received from a company called Grandin Road:
The salutation is friendly enough - "Dear Valued Grandin Road Customer." But I have no recollection of ever buying anything from Grandin Road; the brand name rings no bells with me.
The company goes on to say that it has used an e-mail change-of-address service to make sure it has my preferred e-mail address. This makes it sounds like I had provided Grandin Road an e-mail address and that this is just an update to that. I checked my inbox - I don't have any other e-mail from this company there, not to any of my e-mail addresses.
Even more interesting, the e-mail address it's offering to send e-mail to is a rather obscure one. I used it years ago to sign up for a children's online gaming site (as part of consulting work I did for Hasbro). I still get e-mail messages from that site, but I rarely, if ever, open or click on them. So this wouldn't be considered an "active" e-mail address by many organizations, and if I were using an e-mail change-of-address or append service, I certainly wouldn't want to pay to get this e-mail address.
The next issue is a big one for me as a consumer and as a marketer. Grandin Road is using negative option-opt-out, where silence equals permission. The first bullet tells me that my e-mail address is being added to the list; the second gives me the opportunity to provide a different e-mail address where Grandin Road can reach me. The company is assuming that I want to be on its e-mail list. The option to remove myself from the list is in the footer, in much smaller font.
The end result is this: the Grandin Road list grows overnight, which sounds good. But what is the quality of these names?
Grandin Road also missed an opportunity here. Maybe I would be interested in having an e-mail relationship with this company if I knew more about what products or services it offered, what types of e-mail messages I would receive, and how frequently they would be appearing in my inbox. There's none of that here. The company is assuming that I know what it is; which I don't. And I can't believe I'm the only one.
So, will I remove myself from the list? No, but not for the reasons that Grandin Road wants me on its list.
I'm curious as to how Grandin Road will use this negative option-opt-out introduction to try to entice me to become a customer. Will it attempt to overcome this rocky start to our relationship and make it up to me with e-mail content that's relevant, interesting, and not sent too frequently? Or will it be a constant barrage of "buy, buy, buy" that's all about Grandin Road without any thought to my needs? I'll keep you posted...
Until next time,
August 10-12: Revolutionize your digital marketing campaigns at ClickZ Live San Francisco! Educating marketers for over 15 years, our action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covers every aspect of digital marketing. Early Bird rates available through Friday, July 17 - save up to $300! Register today.
Jeanne Jennings is a recognized expert in the email marketing industry and managing director of digital marketing for Digital Prism Advisors. She has more than 20 years of experience in the email and online marketing and product development world. Jeanne's direct-response approach to digital strategy, tactics, and creative direction helps organizations make their online marketing initiatives more effective and more profitable. Digital Prism Advisors helps established businesses unlock significant growth and revenue opportunities in the digital marketplace; our clients learn to develop and implement successful digital strategies, leveraging data and technology to better meet bottom line goals. Want to learn more? Check out Jeanne's blog and Digital Prisim Advisors.
US Consumer Device Preference Report
Traditionally desktops have shown to convert better than mobile devices however, 2015 might be a tipping point for mobile conversions! Download this report to find why mobile users are more important then ever.
E-Commerce Customer Lifecycle
Have you ever wondered what factors influence online spending or why shoppers abandon their cart? This data-rich infogram offers actionable insight into creating a more seamless online shopping experience across the multiple devices consumers are using.