Back when email newsletters were emerging and publishers were struggling to come up with formats as functional as they were appealing, a newsletter buy often yielded disappointing results. Critical features such as operational unsubscribe links were often disregarded. Little thought was given to crafting enticing subject lines -- though advertisers were counting on newsletters being opened.
Industry competition and the rise of spam have forced publishers to address these issues to prevent their lucrative programs from falling by the wayside. This doesn't mean all are delivering worthy newsletters. Media buyers can choose from thousands of e-newsletters, but only a handful truly deserve their business. How does one distinguish the prized from the poor? Subscribe, analyze, and compare.
In contrast to traditional marketing media, interactive media allows lightning-fast planning and quick-and-dirty campaign execution. Some marketers, however, feel speedy planning underutilizes their skills and deprives them of the opportunity to shape a truly extraordinary marketing strategy.
For this faction, a successful campaign is the product of painstaking planning and lengthy research into each potential media placement. When it comes to buying placements in e- newsletters, all buyers would be wise to take a cue from these media purists.
Because newsletters' style and function vary, buyers can't know their true worth until they've received several mailings. By subscribing to the newsletters you're considering for your client's media plan, you can get a good sense of whether newsletters are consistently delivered in a timely fashion. More important, you can gauge the quality of the subject lines used.
How can you determine the effectiveness of an e-newsletter subject line? The fastest way is to request historical open rates from the publisher and favor newsletters that perform well. (A good performance is subjective; however, a recent industry report claims permission-based email has the potential to receive an open rate as high as 61.4 percent.)
It's also wise to watch for trends over the course of several mailings; you want a subject line that doesn't vary much from edition to edition. If the publisher has done his job, he'll have tested different subject lines to determine which format works best for his publication.
An e-newsletter's content is a big determinant of its value in the eyes of both the advertiser and the consumer. Fresh, original, and engaging content portends well for advertisers, as a happy reader is more apt to see related ads in a positive light.
Personalized content makes for a really great newsletter opportunity. This new trend is setting the standard for email marketing programs. It's no longer atypical for publishers to profile their subscribers, segment their lists, and deliver content specific to their readers' wants and needs. Publishers utilizing this approach are likely to offer more targeted ad placements. An ad is sure to incite a higher response rate if it appears alongside related content in which the reader has indicated an interest.
To best gauge an ad vehicle's success, put yourself in the audience's shoes. Measure potential interest in a newsletter by comparing it to other offerings in the field. The assets of one newsletter are often enhanced when judged against a weaker offering.
A Final Tip
Before subscribing to dozens of newsletters in a quest to find the best, set up a new email account. Using a special email address when subscribing will help deflect additional spam and ensure you don't lose your "research subjects."
Next week, I'll be reviewing some e-newsletters that provide a big bang for your buck. In the meantime, email me with your personal favorites and let me know which ones have worked for you.
Meet Your Favorite ClickZ Contributors
Many of ClickZ's leading expert contributors will be at ClickZ Live, the new online and digital marketing event kicking off in New York (March 31-April 3). Hear from the likes of: Jeremy Hull, Lisa Raehsler, Andrew Goodman, Bryan Eisenberg, Mathew Sweezey, Aaron Kahlow, Stephanie Miller, Simms Jenkins, Jeanne S. Jennings, Dave Hendricks and more!
Tessa Wegert is an interactive media strategist with Enlighten, one of the first full-service digital marketing strategy and services agencies, serving such brands as Bioré, Bratz, Food Network, illy, Hunter Douglas, Jergens, and Olympic Paints and Stains. An industry veteran, Tessa has worked in online media buying and planning, marketing, and online copywriting since 1999. She is an active freelance writer specializing in interactive marketing who has contributed to U.S. and Canadian publications, including "USA Weekend Magazine," "Marketing Magazine," "The Globe and Mail," and "The Montreal Gazette." She is frequently quoted as an industry expert and speaks regularly at industry conferences and events.
March 19, 2014