Home  › Email › Email Marketing

Don't Always Listen to the Experts

  |  March 1, 2010   |  Comments

When considering the advice of experts, ensure that it takes into account your company's - and customers' - needs.

The world of e-mail marketing is a crazy place. If you are a consultant or an industry "expert" you have a tremendous number of great ideas that sound very compelling. However, as a marketer, determining which of those ideas will work for your brand can often be the biggest challenge of all.

For those of you who read my last column, "Getting Real About Results," you might remember that I have engaged the services of a company called Alchemy Worx to employ some out-of-the-box thinking for the e-mail programs I run with my digital magazine. Since then, they have been able to design and deploy a number of tests. Some have proven wildly successful, others not so much.

In the first example, we redesigned our weekly reader communication. We added animated gifs to share the excitement of the interactivity inside the digital magazine.

The next example represents a new e-mail that was developed to drive anticipation and excitement for an upcoming issue.

I have been pre-releasing many of the efforts we are testing to a group of industry experts for comment. Do these experts think these test recommendations will enhance results? Check out the results to see what happened.

Test Type Goal Industry Expert Opinions In-Market Results
Animated gifs Drive clicks Old, outdated approach; stay static Increased clicks 600%
Long subject line Increase opens Will increase deletes; bad idea Increased opens 500%
Day of delivery (Sat.) Reengage readers Weekends don't work well Engaged 5% of prior non-responders
Coming soon e-mail Build loyalty Could work, but generally a waste 2x opens of any other e-mail

Even I was a bit skeptical about a few of these at first, but wanted to see what would happen, as all of these suggestions came from a review of the data and prior results. While I was happy to see such strong short-term growth to what we were doing, this effort made me wonder how much of what we talk about in marketing columns should be applied on a general basis. What if the messenger's message doesn't make sense for your company or brand?

After thinking about it for a bit, I realized that often times industry experts are privy to state-of-the-art technologies and tactics. Some of the more simple best practices seem like they are a bit boring or old school. When was the last time you read an article about the length of your subject line compared to e-mail integrating with social media? Yet, as we innovate, we also must remember to respect the foundational elements that have built this industry into one of the most successful revenue generating industries ever.

The take away from this is simple but important. Don't ignore what you hear at conferences or read in articles. And don't discount what the experts say. Do listen to it carefully and determine exactly how what you are hearing can be personalized so it has the best impact on your efforts. But above all, make sure that your first focus is on ensuring your core/cornerstone efforts are valid and in place. Question everything you have done to this point and revisit each step beginning with some of the items listed above. You may just be surprised at the results.

ClickZ Live San Francisco August 10-12: Revolutionize your digital marketing campaigns at ClickZ Live San Francisco! Educating marketers for over 15 years, our action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covers every aspect of digital marketing. Early Bird rates available through Friday, July 17 - save up to $300! Register today.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Jeanniey Mullen

Jeanniey Mullen is the vice president of marketing at NOOK by Barnes and Noble, focused on business growth and customer acquisition.

Prior to her role at NOOKTM Jeanniey launched a wearables fashion technology company called Ringblingz. Before getting into the wearables business, Jeanniey was the chief marketing officer (CMO) of Zinio, where she grew the business by more than 427 percent, into one of the largest global digital newsstands. Other notable roles in her career include her involvement as the executive director and senior partner at OgilvyOne, where she led the digital Dialogue business and worked with Fortune 50 brands including IBM, Unilever, and American Express, and being a general manager at Grey Direct. At Grey Direct Jeanniey launched the first email marketing division of a global advertising agency. Prior to her time in advertising, Jeanniey spent seven years in retail leading a variety of groups from Consumer Relations and Operations, to Collections and Digital at JCPenney.

One of Jeanniey's favorite times in her career was when she founded the Email Experience Council (which was acquired by the Direct Marketing Association). Jeanniey is a recognized "Women in Business," a frequent keynote speaker, and has authored three books and launched a number of companies ranging from entertainment to technology and fashion.

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

Get ClickZ Email newsletters delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe today!

COMMENTS

UPCOMING EVENTS

Featured White Papers

US Consumer Device Preference Report

US Consumer Device Preference Report
Traditionally desktops have shown to convert better than mobile devices however, 2015 might be a tipping point for mobile conversions! Download this report to find why mobile users are more important then ever.

E-Commerce Customer Lifecycle

E-Commerce Customer Lifecycle
Have you ever wondered what factors influence online spending or why shoppers abandon their cart? This data-rich infogram offers actionable insight into creating a more seamless online shopping experience across the multiple devices consumers are using.

WEBINARS

Jobs

  • Sr. Marketing Specialist, PPC
    Sr. Marketing Specialist, PPC (Charter Communications) - StamfordSr. Marketing Specialist, PPC– Digital Marketing Charter Communications...
  • Online Marketing Analyst
    Online Marketing Analyst (FULLBEAUTY Brands ) - New YorkINTRODUCTION: Are you interested in a unique career opportunity where you can represent...
  • Copy Editor
    Copy Editor (ClickZ / Search Engine Watch) - New YorkROLE OVERVIEW The role of the copy editor for ClickZ has many demands. Ultimately, the copy...