The Five Major Flaws of Link Popularity

  |  February 1, 2001   |  Comments

Link popularity is the new kid in town, and a mighty popular one at that. But don't get swept up in the enthusiasm of the crowd. The kid's not without a few flaws.

More links mean a site must have good content, right? And more links mean more site visitors, right? And surely more links mean better rankings in search engines, right?

Wrong. None of the above is true. In some cases each could be true, but only if you delve a little deeper into the realities of linking in the online world. If a year ago search engine optimization was all the rage, nowadays it's link popularity, and this new kid in town is a mighty popular one.

But while you go about the process of building links, thinking people will beat a path to your site and your search engine rankings will improve, think again. As a measure of quality, rankings improvement, and traffic, link popularity has five major flaws, which explains why search engines can't rely on it too heavily, if at all.

1. New Sites Have No Links

Assume that tomorrow we launch a medical-information site with the deepest and highest quality content of any other site in existence. I'm talking "written by the hand of God"-quality content. The only links we can be assured of are the ones we pay for at Yahoo, LookSmart, NBCi, and Inktomi. The rest we have to get online and make happen. You know the drill -- submit to other engines and ask for links on similar sites or topical directories, engines, and site lists. This is what I do every day for a living. Believe me, all of those medical sites with a few years' head start and 1,500 links are going to be ahead of us for a long, long time, even if our content is better. This example alone proves why links are both a weak metric to use as an indicator of quality and why they're prejudiced against new sites.

2. Links Below Site Level Two Don't Exist

Most search engines index only content in the top two levels of your site. They have no idea that links exist beyond the secondary level simply because they don't search beyond the secondary level. Let's say you have links built to your site from other sites. If these links exist beyond the spiders' allowable depth of travel, they will NEVER be counted. In other words, if you have 5,000 links pointing at your site, but all of them exist on pages beyond the second directory level, a search engine will determine that your site has zero links.

3. Email Links Can't Be Counted

Users spend more time using email than they do surfing the Web. If my site is reviewed in a newsletter that is emailed to 500,000 readers, a search engine doesn't have a clue about it. But I'll take that review and the 100,000 or so new site visitors it sends me any day. Wouldn't you?

4. Spoofers, Free-for-Alls, and Link Schemes Abound

Any time a search engine comes up with a new way to rank pages, someone comes up with a way to trick the search engine. There are already countless links page generation scams and link pyramid schemes where everyone agrees to add your link, and you agree to host the same links page as everyone else.

Forget the quality of the sites themselves, just add the links page to your server. Silly. Any search engine can spot this scam through simple sniffer scripts. Add your link to 6,000 pages in 30 seconds? Ooh, the quality of that content must be something to see.

5. Unauthorized URLs Are Submitted to Search Engines

When the search engine folks first decided to count links, I don't think they ever thought it would inspire people to begin submitting more links than they ever had, including other people's pages. For instance, a marketer has a site and finds a link to his site on another site. In an effort to be sure the search engines know that site has a link to his site, he submits that site to the search engines through the "Add URL" form. Now multiply this marketer's actions times a billion and that's exactly what's happening every day -- people submitting other people's links page to the search engines. This is actually counterproductive because if I found out my links page was being submitted by others I had linked to, I'd pull it from my server.

I've just scratched the surface on the shortcomings of link popularity. Some of them can be fixed, others cannot. And remember, I love the link. I am 100 percent pro-link. The link is literally my life and livelihood. But that's why I study this crazy stuff because there are right and wrong reasons to pursue links, right and wrong ways to ask for them, right and wrong reasons to want them in the first place. Links, in the right places, will determine your ultimate success. And the right places will not be search results.

Until next time, I remain,

Eric Ward,
The Link Mensch


Eric Ward

Eric Ward founded the Web's first link building and content publicity service, called NetPOST. Today, Eric provides strategic linking consulting, link building services, training, and consulting via The publisher of the strategic linking advice newsletter LinkMoses Private, Eric is a co-developer of AdGooroo's Link Insight.

Eric uses his experience and unique understanding of web's vast linking patterns to teach companies his link building techniques. He has developed content linking strategies for, WarnerBros, The Discovery Channel, National Geographic,,, and Eric won the 1995 Tenagra Award for Internet Marketing Excellence, and in 2007 was profiled in the book Online Marketing Heroes.

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

Get the ClickZ Search newsletter delivered to you. Subscribe today!



Featured White Papers

2015 Holiday Email Guide

2015 Holiday Email Guide
The holidays are just around the corner. Download this whitepaper to find out how to create successful holiday email campaigns that drive engagement and revenue.

Three Ways to Make Your Big Data More Valuable

Three Ways to Make Your Big Data More Valuable
Big data holds a lot of promise for marketers, but are marketers ready to make the most of it to drive better business decisions and improve ROI? This study looks at the hidden challenges modern marketers face when trying to put big data to use.