The Risk of Conversion Rate Optimization

  |  September 1, 2006   |  Comments

Are you optimizing your optimization?

What are you doing to increase conversion?

  • Analytics-based optimization

  • A/B testing

  • Online surveys and offline focus groups

  • Site search functionality overhaul

  • Total site redesign

  • Insert your own tactic du jour here

Which tactic requires the most effort and resources? Why did you choose one tactic over another? Can you articulate the risk of your efforts? Have you tried all the above, only to experience marginal improvement?

You're not alone.

A recent ClickZ Features case study detailed how marketers for Universal Orlando have been "tweaking" the site to gain only small conversion growth. Executives wanted large conversion growth and were seeking optimization techniques to reach their goal. (Disclose: my firm worked on the Web site.)

The article quotes Algernon Callier, VP of brand and interactive marketing for Universal Orlando, "When we looked at the idea of redesigning the site, this had come after a good three years of making minor improvements to our existing Web site. We did facelifts, redesigned key pages, and experimented with traditional conversion tactics. We got all the low-hanging fruit."

The Efforts Don't Match the Results

Shop.org's recent "State of Retailing Online" shows the average overall conversion rates declined from 2.6 percent in 2004 to 2.4 percent in 2005.

This is happening despite many of our noble efforts. Since 2004, technology has improved, Web analytics are more prominent; customers are more comfortable buying online, and we're committing more resources to optimization, trying everything from A/B testing to total site redesigns.

Usage of Customer Experience Optimization Tactics Stabilizes
Click on thumb nail to view full-size image
The report also reveals some other interesting morsels. When comparing some common optimization tactics and their effectiveness in 2004 and 2005, many techniques are becoming less effective, not more. And of those techniques that are increasing in their effectiveness, the increase is minimal.

We should be getting better at optimizing, since we've been doing it longer and have more experience. As a byproduct, our conversion rates should be trending upward.

That's not what's happening.

Optimization Tactics Aren't Without Cost

Optimization isn't without risk. Many online practitioners dive directly into optimization tactics without any thought to overarching strategy.

A/B testing may not be a high-risk technique, but would you willing to commit human and financial resources to it if you knew another tactic would produce greater results sooner?

To some, especially those bored with their current sites, a site redesign seems like a no-brainer. Yet many redesigns throw the baby out with the bathwater. A site redesign may be the riskiest of all tactics, especially if you break what's currently working on your site in the name of having something newer, flashier, and prettier.

When effort begins to outsize expected results, it's time to evaluate your optimization regimen. Stop throwing these well-adopted tactics at the wall to see what sticks. Optimize your optimization.

Signs You Need More Than Optimization Techniques

  • Marketing in silos. Many larger companies have too many chefs cooking up sometimes slightly, sometimes drastically different marketing experiences across too many channels. Optimizing successes and failures aren't communicated well within the company, not to mention efforts aren't synchronized for a more consistent customer experience.

  • Giving up too soon. Many companies cast a technique into the river. If they don't bring up a fish after a few casts, they're abandoned.

  • Optimizing too many wrong assumptions. Many companies correctly identify where problems occur but incorrectly try to fix things with a hammer when they really need a wrench. Are you changing the color or shape of a button when the culprit might be a lack of a point-of-action assurance?

  • Thinking too small. Are you trying to optimize a single pipeline at the expense of others? Are you applying too much effort to selling today? You can convert today and load up several pipelines for future conversions.

Methodology vs. Techniques

If you're worn out by your optimization efforts, consider this: As a visitor arrives at your site, thousands of variables affect her ability to convert. To that, add the fact you have many visitor types with many different needs. Multiply this by each product or service line you offer. These variables also change.

What are the odds of finding the ultimate set of variables for maximum conversion on any given page? How much creative time, effort, and resources are you willing to experiment with until you find out?

Talent can find some wins when optimizing, but alone it can't account for, test, track, and execute successful implementation with that many variables at play.

Online marketers need a robust, efficient process to make these variables manageable. Marketers need a predictive model of customer behavior, a model that can help prioritize and measure optimization efforts and steer them away from fruitless efforts.

Said Callier in the above-mentioned Features article, "The approach takes into account human decision making styles. It's beyond demographic, beyond male/female, young/old. It gets into the psychology of how humans make decisions and how they get comfortable making decisions."

The Universal Orlando site was built on persuasion scenarios that manage these variables by design and make them accountable to a few more stable variables, normal human psychographic behavior, and customer and business goals. The results? The new site beat the old on 30 of 40 qualitative and quantitative measurements, "including likeability." According to the case study, "Online ticket purchases, a key metric for the resort, are up almost 80 percent year to date."

Are you still throwing stuff against the wall to see what sticks and wondering why you aren't extremely satisfied? There's a way to clean up the mess.

ClickZ Live San Francisco This Year's Premier Digital Marketing Event is #CZLSF
ClickZ Live San Francisco (Aug 11-14) brings together the industry's leading practitioners and marketing strategists to deliver 4 days of educational sessions and training workshops. From Data-Driven Marketing to Social, Mobile, Display, Search and Email, this year's comprehensive agenda will help you maximize your marketing efforts and ROI. Register today!

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Bryan Eisenberg

Bryan Eisenberg is coauthor of the Wall Street Journal, Amazon, BusinessWeek, and New York Times bestselling books "Call to Action," "Waiting For Your Cat to Bark?," and "Always Be Testing." Bryan is a professional marketing speaker and has keynoted conferences globally such as SES, Shop.org, Direct Marketing Association, MarketingSherpa, Econsultancy, Webcom, SEM Konferansen Norway, the Canadian Marketing Association, and others. In 2010, Bryan was named a winner of the Direct Marketing Educational Foundation's Rising Stars Awards, which recognizes the most talented professionals 40 years of age or younger in the field of direct/interactive marketing. He is also cofounder and chairman emeritus of the Web Analytics Association. Bryan serves as an advisory board member of SES Conference & Expo, the eMetrics Marketing Optimization Summit, and several venture capital backed companies. He works with his coauthor and brother Jeffrey Eisenberg. You can find them at BryanEisenberg.com.

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

Get the ClickZ Analytics newsletter delivered to you. Subscribe today!

COMMENTS

UPCOMING EVENTS

Featured White Papers

BigDoor: The Marketers Guide to Customer Loyalty

The Marketer's Guide to Customer Loyalty
Customer loyalty is imperative to success, but fostering and maintaining loyalty takes a lot of work. This guide is here to help marketers build, execute, and maintain a successful loyalty initiative.

Marin Software: The Multiplier Effect of Integrating Search & Social Advertising

The Multiplier Effect of Integrating Search & Social Advertising
Latest research reveals 68% higher revenue per conversion for marketers who integrate their search & social advertising. In addition to the research results, this whitepaper also outlines 5 strategies and 15 tactics you can use to better integrate your search and social campaigns.

WEBINARS

    Information currently unavailable

Jobs

    • Interactive Product Manager
      Interactive Product Manager (Western Governors University) - Salt Lake CityWestern Governors University, one of the 20 largest universities...
    • SEO Senior Analyst
      SEO Senior Analyst (University of Phoenix (Apollo Education Group)) - San FranciscoSEO Senior Analyst   Position Summary...
    • SEM & Biddable Media Manager
      SEM & Biddable Media Manager (Kepler Group LLC) - New YorkAs an Optimization & Innovation Manager at Kepler Group, you will be on the bleeding...