SEOs, PRs, and agencies are duking it out for social media marketing turf. Who should win?
Not so terribly long ago, it wasn't uncommon for companies to entrust their online presence to the nearest digital savant at hand -- and savant was a word that was taken lightly. Online gurus often materialized in the form of teenage children, geeky neighbors, and entrepreneurial types taking a step up from desktop publishing ventures.
Needless to say, it didn't take long for best practices and professionals to emerge and take over. It doesn't matter how well your 13 year old neighbor knows HTML. Because let's face it, adolescents who can combine tactical skills with developing and executing a solid business strategy are few and far between. Even in a virtual world, the laws of nature still apply.
Now that the who-builds-the-Web-site issue is much, much clearer, a newer digital frontier is muddying the whose-job-is-it waters. So whose job is social media, anyway?
Once again, not a few business owners eager to dip a toe into the promises of participatory digital media are looking to the teenager next door for "professional" assistance. After all, aren't they the pioneers of social media sites such as MySpace and Facebook? Does having a Twitter account qualify you as a social media marketing guru? Not bloody likely -- but who is qualified to hang out a shingle as a "social media marketing consultant" remains very much up for grabs.
The PRs Versus the Searchies
Who should own social media? Public relations (PR) professionals are certainly putting a stake into the ground, and not without reason. After all, a huge component of the participatory Internet is seeding information: stories, content, and news, and helping to foster dissemination.
Looking on with alarm, however are the SEOs (define). Search engine optimization is, after all, a form of public relations. Just as there are no guarantees that "The New York Times" is going to write a story based on your press release, much less run it on page one, there's no guarantee search engines will crawl or highly rank your Web content. But if you know what youÃÂ¢Ã¯Â¿Â½Ã¯Â¿Â½re doing, you can greatly increase the odds of a favorable outcome.
Left in the hands of PRs, argue the searchies, social media marketing will turn into a tidal wave of spam. We're the Internet professionals -- leave it to us!
They kinda have a point -- but as with all professional assessments, it depends on qualifications. I wouldn't hesitate to hand an online social media campaign to a firm such as
But theirs are skills honed by years of experience, education, and technical proficiency. The other side of the spectrum is an old acquaintance who's been in PR forever (let's call her "Susan") whose business failed in the current economic climate. Susan joined Facebook a few weeks ago, which she uses to send frequent reminders to her network that she's desperately seeking freelance assignments. Beyond Facebook and an e-mail account, Susan's knowledge of the Web is pretty close to zero. Much as I'd like to help out an old friend in need, I could not in good conscience recommend Susan's services to anyone in my own network.
The other side of the search versus PR equation? While PRs tend to (or should) excel at communication and creatively generating and disseminating content, search skills often tend to be more technical and geekier. Yet I know of at least one major player in search about to walk away from his SEO/SEM firm to form a new venture in the social media space. But this person's skill set includes years of deep involvement with major global ad agencies and plenty of exposure to the creative and strategic side of building campaigns.
Where Do Agencies Fit In?
Oh, right -- ad agencies. Shouldn't they be duking it out for social media turf, too?
Of course they are. And while many agencies deeply understand the digital landscape, as well as possess strong capabilities in search and in communications, social media marketing skews well off the list of agencies' core competency, which is creating and placing advertising. Social media is marketing, not that discipline's advertising subset.
But as traditional offline advertising channels suffer from pressures from which they're unlikely ever to fully recover, and as online advertising is on the decline sparked not online by economic woes, but by the rise of alternatives -- such as social media -- agencies will have to shift their skill sets to effectively get in on the game. And they will -- many already are, of course. They have to if they want to follow the marketing dollars. And like the SEOs, the PRs, and other players in digital marketing, agencies, too must learn new skills, new business models, and innovate new ways to integrate campaigns into another large and growing subset of channels.
In that sense, there's no difference on the professional level of social media from the user level. Social media belongs to everyone. And no one.
What's New for 2015?
You spoke, we listened! ClickZ Live New York (Mar 30-Apr 1) is back with a brand new streamlined agenda. Don't miss the latest digital marketing tips, tricks and tools that will make you re-think your strategy and revolutionize your marketing campaigns. Super Saver Rates are available now. Register today!
Rebecca was previously VP, U.S. operations of Econsultancy, an independent source of advice and insight on digital marketing and e-commerce. Earlier, she held executive marketing and communications positions at strategic e-services companies, including Siegel & Gale, and has worked in the same capacity for global entertainment and media companies, including Universal Television & Networks Group (formerly USA Networks International) and Bertelsmann's RTL Television. As a journalist, she's written on media for numerous publications, including "The New York Times" and "The Wall Street Journal." Rebecca spent five years as Variety's Berlin-based German/Eastern European bureau chief. Rebecca also taught at New York University's Center for Publishing, where she also served on the Electronic Publishing Advisory Group. Rebecca, author of "The Truth About Search Engine Optimization," was ClickZ's editor-in-chief for over seven years.
Singapore, 3-4 November
Hong Kong, 8-9 December
Hong Kong, 8-9 December
Google My Business Listings Demystified
To help brands control how they appear online, Google has developed a new offering: Google My Business Locations. This whitepaper helps marketers understand how to use this powerful new tool.
5 Ways to Personalize Beyond the Subject Line
82 percent of shoppers say they would buy more items from a brand if the emails they sent were more personalized. This white paper offer five tactics that will personalize your email beyond the subject line and drive real business growth.