How viable is the idea of building your own in-house affiliate solution? There are not many situations where it would be advantageous to do this. One reader indicated an interest in acquiring a large number of members for an opt-in marketing program. Using this as a hypothetical scenario, Joel walks you through the options and the numbers.
A common reader gripe goes something like this...
Honestly? I can't think of too many situations where it would be advantageous to build your own program. Recently someone wrote in to express an interest in acquiring a large number of members for an opt-in, permission-based marketing program. Since this is a desire shared by many, we'll use it as a hypothetical scenario.
Some Quick Math
Assume you were willing to spend $1 per member sign-up. The average affiliate network charges an additional 20 percent, or $0.20 per member sign-up. This means an affiliate marketer could sign up 500,000 members for every $100,000 in network fees it incurred. Now assume you wanted to achieve this volume month after month; that's a total of six million members in your first year.
Where Do Your Affiliates Come From?
How many affiliates do you think you'll need to recruit in order to drive 500,000 sign-ups monthly? If you're not sure of the exact number, a bit of speculation should help. If a typical affiliate web site serves 10,000 page-views monthly and your offer gets a two percent CTR, followed by a ten percent conversion rate, you're looking at 20 sign-ups per affiliate per month on average. That means you'd need about 25,000 active affiliates to generate 500,000 sign-ups. Recalling that the 80/20 rule applies, expect to recruit about 125,000 affiliates in order to net 25,000 actives.
If you're paying $1 per end-user sign-up, how much will it cost you to recruit new affiliates? Maybe $5, maybe $10? After all, if you're not in an affiliate network, how will affiliates find you? How much marketing will be required to attract affiliates directly to your program? Make sure to factor these costs into your "savings" estimates for going it alone.
Other Points to Consider
Does your company write its own payroll checks? If you don't handle your own employees' paychecks, why would you take on the task of writing checks to 25,000 affiliates?
Does your company run its own ad servers? In order to serve affiliate commerce offers, you'll need some type of banner- serving capability. If you already outsource this capability, there's no point in bringing it in-house. Likewise, the better affiliate networks serve your banners and offers as part of their standard commission. That's a far cry from most third-party ad service bureaus, which charge on a CPM basis.
Finally, does your company have an existing customer service organization capable of answering technical questions about HTML code? For most companies this is the final showstopper. Even if you do have a great customer service group, odds are you don't want to take them away from your true end-customer.
What Do Affiliate Networks Provide?
Service levels and pricing do vary tremendously from network to network. What you should be looking to get from your affiliate network depends on your exact situation. For my money, an affiliate network should provide a robust stable of affiliates. Next, an affiliate partner should be capable of handling check writing, 1099s, banner serving and frontline technical support.
Going back to our example, during the course of 12 months you could expect to recruit six million opt-in members for a cost in network fees of around $1.2 million. Then add to this the commissions paid to your affiliates. All told, $7.2 million has acquired you a meaningful base of members.
Not impressed? Consider Lifeminders, which just passed the 12 million member mark in March, a feat that took them a mere 15 months. For better or worse, Lifeminders spent an average of about $5 per member. Hmmm... $1.20 a member doesn't sound so bad, does it?
Want to learn more?
Join us at ClickZ Live New York this March 30 - April 1. With over 15 years' experience delivering industry leading events, ClickZ Live brings together over 50 expert speakers to offer an action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covering all aspects of digital marketing. Register today to secure your place and save $300!
Joel Gehman is the creator of AffiliateHandbook.com. He consults, writes, and speaks about the dynamics of affiliate marketing.
Singapore, 5-6 March
Bangkok, 17-18 March
Hong Kong, April 2015
A Buyer's Guide to Affiliate Management Software
Manage your performance marketing with the right solution. Choose a platform that will mutually empower advertisers and media partners!
Google My Business Listings Demystified
To help brands control how they appear online, Google has developed a new offering: Google My Business Locations. This whitepaper helps marketers understand how to use this powerful new tool.
March 3, 2015
1:00pm ET/10:00am PT