Bloodletting and Why Testing Can Be Unscientific

  |  February 4, 2002   |  Comments

If you think taking a purely scientific approach to improving your conversion rates is the answer, you're kidding yourself.

Zach, my good friend's son, answers the phone. He is in the middle of trying to solve one of those verbal math problems that go like this: "Bob is walking at 3 miles per hour, and Jim is walking at 1.5 miles per hour. They have to walk 30 miles. What kind of head start does Jim need to get there at the same time as Bob?" Helping Zach figure out an answer wasn't difficult, but getting the answer wasn't the only goal of this exercise. The more important objective was to develop an understanding of how to solve these types of problems.

Most of us know that H2O is water. Nevertheless, most of us don't have a thorough understanding of chemistry. The art and science of conversion rate marketing is similar. It's not just about getting higher conversion rates by experimenting with the variables. Awareness of the variables and how they relate to each other are crucial. Solving the problem of getting better conversion results is as much an exercise in understanding why something works as it is in understanding what to do.

If Zach simply knew the answer, he would have knowledge -- he would be able to recite correct information. If he gets the solution, he has wisdom -- he knows what makes it work. For him to achieve understanding, he has to know why it works; he has to comprehend fully the relationship between all the variables in the problem and its solution, so he can apply this effectively to any number of similar verbal math problems.

Think for a moment about an email message for which we want to improve response rates. If it helps, read this article by my fellow ClickZ author, Al DiGuido. Most of us are forced to start at the highest testing ground (the email delivery), where there are few signposts to illustrate success. We don't spend the time to prove techniques on lower elemental levels. This is like trying to build a pyramid by starting with the top block. To possess a complete understanding of how to create emails that drive action and build relationships, it is not enough for us to develop a science based on systems we make to test our "creative." We must be able to recognize, predict, and duplicate the elements that create the persuasive process.

Persuading is influencing opinions or affecting attitudes by means of communication. It means not only informing but also providing new information to the readers so they can make decisions. It also requires motivating people. It means affecting the hearts as well as the minds of people (a message has to have emotional appeal while possessing rational elements).

We know that if we were to merge two elements of hydrogen with one element of oxygen, we would create water and we could duplicate this process repeatedly. This is knowledge. Knowing how to put these two elements together is wisdom. Knowing why these two elements bond and have the properties that they do is understanding. If I tell you the formula for water is H2O and say that it is a "rule," I'm not giving you the understanding to do more than just make water.

A science based on rules creates a technician; an art and science based on fundamental principles create a visionary. An artist creating by rules produces paint-by-number pictures; an artist creating by fundamental principles produces works the likes of Monet, Rembrandt, and Picasso. The danger in crafting persuasive creative based on rules is that it becomes predictable and our readers (prospects) begin to tune it out (especially when 3,000 commercial messages a day come at you). Should it be a rule that personalized subject lines deliver higher open rates? I hope you understand the answer is no. Do they often work better? Yes. The important question to answer is: Why do they work better? Maybe the subject line without the personalization did not grab any attention at all, and including the name grabbed just a bit more than zero.

A perfect example: One of the world's largest personal goods manufacturers had wonderful records and had discovered which advertisements throughout its history were the most effective. As the managers went through each and every advertisement, they could not figure out what made them successful. On the surface, they all seemed to be randomly different. What was the similarity? I can't share with you the secret of exactly what it was, but I will reveal that it had to do with an understanding of the human mind's attraction to chaotic systems.

There is a human need for rules, especially in the Web's technology-worshipping culture. Just look at the demand for successful books and articles out there with titles incorporating things like seven habits, nine rules, and 12 mistakes (we do it, too, because people want it). The left brain demands control while the right brain insists on freedom. Left- and right-brain concepts collide in your cranium every day. We constantly struggle with choices between cold logic and heartfelt intuition, control or liberty, exactness or beauty.

The process for persuading human beings to take action is indeed a system, but it's not a hard science based on predictable rules that could produce perfectly replicable results in a laboratory. People who believe it is remind me of the "medical experts" who once went around treating patients with leeches. After all, they thought they were being scientific.

Are you looking for rules or principles? Will your scientific tests ignore the fact that the single most important variable in your experiment is unknowable? Will you invest the effort in understanding what creates emails that drive action and build relationships, or will you be caught up in the pseudoscience of randomly testing to see what works? If it's the latter, don't forget to bring your leeches.

ClickZ Live San Francisco Revolutionize your digital marketing campaigns at ClickZ Live San Francisco (August 10-12)!
Educating marketers for over 15 years, our action-packed, educationally-focused agenda offers 9 tracks to cover every aspect of digital marketing. Join over 500 digital marketers and expert speakers from leading brands. Register today!

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Bryan Eisenberg

Bryan Eisenberg is co-founder and chief marketing officer (CMO) of IdealSpot. He is co-author of the Wall Street Journal, Amazon, BusinessWeek, and New York Times best-selling books Call to Action, Waiting For Your Cat to Bark?, and Always Be Testing, and Buyer Legends. Bryan is a keynote speaker and has keynoted conferences globally such as Gultaggen, Shop.org, Direct Marketing Association, MarketingSherpa, Econsultancy, Webcom, the Canadian Marketing Association, and others for the past 10 years. Bryan was named a winner of the Marketing Edge's Rising Stars Awards, recognized by eConsultancy members as one of the top 10 User Experience Gurus, selected as one of the inaugural iMedia Top 25 Marketers, and has been recognized as most influential in PPC, Social Selling, OmniChannel Retail. Bryan serves as an advisory board member of several venture capital backed companies such as Sightly, UserTesting, Monetate, ChatID, Nomi, and BazaarVoice. He works with his co-author and brother Jeffrey Eisenberg. You can find them at BryanEisenberg.com.

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

Get the ClickZ Analytics newsletter delivered to you. Subscribe today!

COMMENTS

UPCOMING EVENTS

Featured White Papers

US Consumer Device Preference Report

US Consumer Device Preference Report
Traditionally desktops have shown to convert better than mobile devices however, 2015 might be a tipping point for mobile conversions! Download this report to find why mobile users are more important then ever.

E-Commerce Customer Lifecycle

E-Commerce Customer Lifecycle
Have you ever wondered what factors influence online spending or why shoppers abandon their cart? This data-rich infogram offers actionable insight into creating a more seamless online shopping experience across the multiple devices consumers are using.

WEBINARS

Resources

Jobs

  • Sr. Marketing Specialist, PPC
    Sr. Marketing Specialist, PPC (Charter Communications) - StamfordSr. Marketing Specialist, PPC– Digital Marketing Charter Communications...