Home  › Marketing › Strategies

Paid Search Doesn't Scale for Brand Advertisers

  |  May 7, 2007   |  Comments

Paid search is successful because it's a self-generating pool of highly targeted inventory that converts very well. But why doesn't it work for brand advertisers?

Inventory across all advertising types can be sorted into three classes:

  • High eCPM (define) direct response (DR) inventory. This highly targeted inventory drives high conversions due to audience self-identification. Frequently, the target's granularity makes it impossible or inefficient to reach a large audience. Examples include targeted mailing lists and paid search listings.

  • High eCPM brand inventory. This inventory enables a highly efficient way to purchase access to the advertiser's largest possible target audience. It's broken into two types: highly targeted narrow-reach (small, valuable audience) inventory and very broad reach inventory associated with either high-quality content or a valuable interest area (autos, finance, etc.) that offers advertisers access to an efficient buy of a large or targeted audience or both. Examples include prime-time TV shows, Web portal home pages (MSN.com, Yahoo.com), niche magazines, automotive Web sites, and financial Web sites.

  • Low eCPM DR inventory. This undifferentiated inventory either doesn't offer a good brand advertising experience or doesn't convert particularly well. Frequently, it doesn't offer great branding opportunities and can be inefficient to buy. Examples include classified ads, yellow pages, Web-based mail (Hotmail, Yahoo Mail), remnant online display inventory, and contextual inventory aggregated from publishers too small to matter on their own.

Note that budgets for companies that spend a lot of money on advertising are typically designated to the first, second, and third categories -- in that order.

In the inventory hierarchy, high-performance DR inventory will always sell out first, and at high CPMs. Any advertiser's DR budget is spent to the maximum available pool of inventory, but there isn't enough inventory in existence that works well for DR at high CPMs. The rest of the DR world exists in inventory that's very low value, bought at low CPMs based purely on very careful ROI analysis.

What many people, even in the advertising industry, don't realize is nearly every company that can make use of direct marketing will spend as much money on direct marketing inventory in the first category as is available to them. As long as the media buy has positive ROI (define), they'll spend an unlimited amount of money on as much of this inventory type as they can find. Since inventory is limited, most companies can't drive all their sales in this channel and, therefore, must spend money on other advertising forms. Most companies go after a mix of brand and inexpensive DR inventory to drive additional sales.

Because high eCPM DR inventory has low supply and is in high demand, its eCPM is nearly always optimized by the market. Paid search companies optimize it further by selling their inventory via real-time auctions, which dynamically optimize inventory yield on their behalf (Google always makes the most money it can for each keyword.)

This inventory type includes highly qualified, targeted mailing lists or leads. Typically, these mailing lists or sales leads are generated as a result of request for information (RFI) cards (those little cards in magazines that you rarely fill out) or people who specifically asked to be contacted by salespeople. Companies like LendingTree exist because they collect contact information from people who are looking for mortgages and sell those leads to mortgage companies. This leads to highly qualified lists of people looking for mortgages, which tends to drive high eCPM for the company that owns the inventory.

Paid search has been successful because it's a self-generating pool of highly targeted inventory that converts well because the audience is far down the sales funnel and the audience self-identifies their interest. If you're searching for a type of car and your search is very granular, such as "seven-passenger SUV," most companies trying to sell cars that match your search query will pay a lot for the resulting paid search inventory.

But highly targeted keyword groups are rare, so they tend to be expensive. And since most companies only have a few products or services, a vast number of advertisers are needed to drive up prices due to competition. This is the magic created by the paid search space. High-yielding inventory for the publisher, high eCPM payouts by the advertiser, and very relevant advertising for the consumer are a winning combination and a new channel of granular, targeted inventory.

While search engines typically sell out their inventory at a high eCPM in aggregate, few customers spend a lot with them. Most advertisers spending on paid search are small businesses that don't use any other advertising form. Companies like eBay and Amazon are among the few with vast numbers of products to attach to a vast number of keywords. And while these companies are among the search engines' largest customers, they typically represent only a small percentage of the engines' revenue.

This is very different from what we see in high eCPM brand inventory. In this inventory class, an advertiser can spend a lot of money to reach a large audience in a very efficient manner. The types of inventory in this category are owned by the largest media companies and are typically bought and sold in a relatively high-touch process.

The huge existing pool of brand advertising dollars simply can't be spent in search. There isn't a way to buy a large enough audience. There isn't enough brand-driving quality (text ads aren't nearly as memorable as video or rich media). And there's simply too much friction in paid search to let a brand media buyer capture a large relevant audience. This, of course, is the desire of most major ad spenders: to hit a large relevant audience, with emphasis on "large" first, "relevant" second. They simply can't spend large amounts of money on paid search efficiently enough -- and they don't get a big enough brand benefit from that inventory as it is.

Join us for the ClickZ Specifics: Advertising in Social Media seminar on May 21 in New York.

Want more search information? ClickZ SEM Archives contain all our search columns, organized by topic.

ClickZ Live New York Want to learn more?
Attend ClickZ Live New York March 30 - April 1. With over 15 years' experience delivering industry-leading events, ClickZ Live brings together over 60 expert speakers to offer an action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covering all aspects of digital marketing. Register today!


Eric Picard Eric Picard is the director of advertising strategy and emerging media planning at Microsoft Digital Advertising Solutions. In his role, he helps set corporate-level strategy for how Microsoft approaches advertising from a business and technology standpoint. His team manages long-term advertising platform and product strategy, emerging media strategy, and planning for incubation and research teams, and designs next generation advertising products. Formerly, Eric was founder and director of product management at Bluestreak, where he oversaw advertising products, such as third-party ad serving, ad analytics, and rich media and led development of many company technologies. He helped pioneer rich media advertising in the late '90s and has been active in most of the critical industry conversations related to technology, including the IAB's Measurement Committee and Rich Media Task Force. Prior to Bluestreak, Eric founded 9th Square Inc. and Waterworks Interactive Inc.

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

Get the ClickZ Marketing newsletter delivered to you. Subscribe today!




Featured White Papers

A Buyer's Guide to Affiliate Management Software

A Buyer's Guide to Affiliate Management Software
Manage your performance marketing with the right solution. Choose a platform that will mutually empower advertisers and media partners!

Google My Business Listings Demystified

Google My Business Listings Demystified
To help brands control how they appear online, Google has developed a new offering: Google My Business Locations. This whitepaper helps marketers understand how to use this powerful new tool.


    • Website Optimizer - SEO, CRO, Analytics
      Website Optimizer - SEO, CRO, Analytics (Marcel Digital) - ChicagoMarcel Digital, an award winning interactive marketing agency established in 2003...
    • Director of Marketing
      Director of Marketing (Patron Technology) - New YorkDirector of Marketing We are seeking a Director of Marketing to manage and build our marketing...
    • Senior Interactive Producer
      Senior Interactive Producer (Ready Set Rocket) - New YorkWhat You'll Do As a member of our team, the Senior Producer reports directly to our...