Consider these seven lessons before working with a third-party e-mail list provider. Second in a two-part series.
In my last column, I introduced you to a small consumer goods company with some big plans for boosting sales during the holiday season. The president of the company, who we'll call Bill, was just embarking on a multieffort marketing campaign to a third-party e-mail list.
Last time we talked about what Bill was told about the list, including price as well as anticipated open and click-through rates. I cited some red flags. Today we'll cover the result of his sends.
Bill's first e-mail went out just before Thanksgiving -- prime time for gift marketers. When I inquired about how it was doing, he responded, "A disaster thus far. One sale so far, and not attributed to the campaign...because they used a coupon from a coupon site. The [Web analytics] stats are not even on the map... It makes we wonder if the blast even happened."
To help Bill out, I did a quick, very basic deliverability check, using the IP address and domain that the e-mail was sent from. My results were three for three. Senderbase.org, ReputationAuthority, and BarracudaCentral.org all showed deliverability issues.
On Senderbase.org (run by Cisco), the server's e-mail reputation score was "poor," which is defined as "a problematic level of threat activity has been observed from your IP address or domain. Your e-mail or Web traffic is likely to be filtered or blocked."
ReputationAuthority reported a high rate of spam (74 percent of all e-mail sent) coming from the IP address and noted that it appeared on four DNS block lists hosted by BorderWare (the company behind ReputationAuthority). It also showed that the e-mail from this domain name was being sent from four servers, with reported spam rates of 77 to 95 percent.
The check on BarracudaCentral.org (run by Barracuda Networks), confirmed that the IP address had a "poor" rating and noted that Barracuda was blocking the domain that the e-mail was sent from.
Bill didn't believe the e-mail had been sent; my research suggested that it had, indeed, been sent, but that little if any of it had been delivered.
When Bill presented this information to the list company, the IT person responded, saying she was "alarmed" and would do some of her own research. She wondered "how [the e-mail] could be detected as spam if the people have opted in with them." She said she spoke to someone at Barracuda who told her that e-mail from reputable companies are often "spooked" (I think she meant "spoofed") and that this could be causing the deliverability issues. All true, but understanding spoofing doesn't help the e-mail get delivered.
For his second send, Bill asked that he be able to review the Web sites I listed above and choose the server/IP address that would be used. The list company agreed, although he was later told that this was "unheard of." He chose a server with a "good" reputation.
The second send had results similar to the first. No sales, no increase in Web traffic, no return for Bill's investment (which was significant for his business). When I checked the reputations of the IP address and domain after the send, they were back to "poor," suggesting further deliverability problems.
The list company finally provided some basic metrics. Instead of the 12 to 18 percent open rate it had cited in its initial offering, Bill's e-mail got open rates of 0.43 and 0.18 percent. The click-through rates were 0.05 and 0.04 percent, a fraction of the 11 to 21 percent rates he was quoted by the list company.
When asked, the list company blamed Bill's e-mail creative, but they had no suggestions for improvement. I reviewed the subject line and creative for both sends; it was good stuff and incorporated e-mail standards and best practices. With a good list, it should have delivered traffic to the Web site, if not sales; with a poor list and/or deliverability issues, it doesn't really make a difference what you send.
Bill was told that after the initial sends, he could download the list, load it into his own e-mail service provider (ESP), and send from there. I discouraged him; all legitimate ESPs require lists be opt-in. This list, where people opted in to receive e-mail from a third party (as the list company claims, we have no proof), not from Bill, doesn't meet that criteria. If he receives spam complaints, he could be kicked off his ESP -- and he could have trouble finding another ESP to take his business.
No list company will guarantee results. But the best ones know the rules of the e-mail road and abide by them. Protect yourself to avoid spending good money for bad results.
Revolutionize your digital marketing campaigns at ClickZ Live San Francisco (August 10-12)!
Educating marketers for over 15 years, our action-packed, educationally-focused agenda offers 9 tracks to cover every aspect of digital marketing. Join over 500 digital marketers and expert speakers from leading brands. Register today!
Jeanne Jennings is a recognized expert in the email marketing industry and managing director of digital marketing for Digital Prism Advisors. She has more than 20 years of experience in the email and online marketing and product development world. Jeanne's direct-response approach to digital strategy, tactics, and creative direction helps organizations make their online marketing initiatives more effective and more profitable. Digital Prism Advisors helps established businesses unlock significant growth and revenue opportunities in the digital marketplace; our clients learn to develop and implement successful digital strategies, leveraging data and technology to better meet bottom line goals. Want to learn more? Check out Jeanne's blog and Digital Prisim Advisors.
US Consumer Device Preference Report
Traditionally desktops have shown to convert better than mobile devices however, 2015 might be a tipping point for mobile conversions! Download this report to find why mobile users are more important then ever.
E-Commerce Customer Lifecycle
Have you ever wondered what factors influence online spending or why shoppers abandon their cart? This data-rich infogram offers actionable insight into creating a more seamless online shopping experience across the multiple devices consumers are using.