Last week, Twitter (finally) revealed its first real monetization plans: an advertising offering it's dubbed, "Promoted Tweets." I had planned to write on a different topic for this week's column, but having authored a new book on Twitter marketing, I feel compelled to change course. I also feel compelled to comment upon what's beginning to feel like weekly schoolyard one-upmanship between Google, Apple, Twitter, and Facebook. Don't get me wrong. I'm glad to see innovations and vibrancy in our space. I'm just beginning to wonder how much Kool-Aid we're all supposed to drink. But enough of this tinge of cynicism: on to more Twitter advertising!
Latest Twitter Stats
Twitter has its share of naysayers, but at its recent developers conference, Chirp, Twitter co-founder Biz Stone divulged some stats that show it's certainly no lightweight player:
Promoted Tweets in a Nutshell
Twitter's Promoted Tweets will look and function like all other tweets, i.e., limited to 140 characters, except they will be flagged at the bottom as "Promoted by [Name of Advertiser]."
Of course, we would expect Promoted Tweets to have blatant offers and ad messages...not that users and brands aren't already crafting such tweets.
At first, Promoted Tweets will appear only in Twitter Search results, at the top of the page, with a limit of one Promoted Tweet per page. (Ironically, as of this writing Twitter doesn't seem to be running its own Promoted Tweets within Twitter Search when you search for "Promoted Tweets.")
Twitter intends to track and analyze the value and staying power of an ad with a "Resonance Score," taking into account such factors as user retweets, favoriting, and replies. Twitter says it will take down ads that don't have a high enough score. (We wonder if Twitter has also considered a thumbs-up/thumbs-down user vote to help determine the Resonance Score?)
At Promoted Tweets' formal unveiling at last week's Ad Age Digital Conference, COO Dick Costolo revealed that ad data and analytics will be available to advertisers in real time, but the dashboard, as well as the mechanics for campaign purchasing and set-up is still shrouded in mystery. Beta advertisers seem to have been hand-selected, and all we know about pricing is that it's currently on a CPM (define) basis.
Presumably, if this grand experiment works, Twitter will soon open itself up to other advertisers. Eventually, too, Twitter says that Promoted Tweets will be open to third-party Twitter clients (with speculation that a possible revenue share deal would be worked out) and then later will appear in-stream in users' timelines.
I'm somewhat surprised that Twitter's first move into monetization is Promoted Tweets. Not that I don't think there's money to be made by Twitter this way (heck, look at what Google's been able to accomplish), but I'd have thought Twitter would first pursue a non-advertising route, particularly because of adverse user reaction.
Also, the real-time nature of Twitter makes relevant advertising a high-maintenance play. This might make managing Promoted Tweets more like paid search campaigns than display ones. Into whose lap will campaign management responsibility fall: media's or search's?
Speaking of search, Costolo admitted that Twitter's search is but a fraction of its traffic (read: low ad inventory). My experience with Twitter Search is that while it can be useful to datamine, it's far from an easy or perfect science, so I'm less apt to use it when I have to find information, particularly any information beyond the most recent few days or so.
Combine this with Google's recent addition of Twitter's archive to its "replay search," which is integrated with live, real-time tweets simultaneously, and one has to wonder if Google started serving advertising here, who's going to come ahead at monetizing tweet searches. (Check out this Google "replay" for Starbucks to get a comparative value. Notice on Google you can easily move your timeline view and go all the way back to February 2010 if you wanted to. Twitter Search doesn't make that possible.)
Will Promoted Tweets make my media plan one day? Maybe, but it'll probably be just a sliver for a long while.
Upcoming Webinar: PPC Pause and Reflections for 2013
Thursday, December 12 - 2013 was a major turning point in search advertising. With Google's Enhanced Campaigns and Bing's innovative Smart Search capabilities in Windows 8.1, now is a great time to pause, reflect, and plan for the new year.
Webinar attendance is free. Sign up today!
A ClickZ expert columnist since 2005, Hollis Thomases (@hollisthomases) is president and founder of Maryland-based WebAdvantage.net, an online marketing company that provides results-centric, strategic Internet marketing services, including online media planning, SEO, PPC campaign management, social media marketing, and Internet consulting. Author of Twitter Marketing: An Hour a Day and an award-winning entrepreneur, Hollis is the Maryland 2007 SBA Small Business Person of the Year. Hollis speaks extensively on online marketing, having presented for ClickZ, the American Marketing Association, SES, The Newsletter and Electronic Publishers Association, The Kelsey Group, and the Vocus Worldwide User Forum. WebAdvantage.net's client list has included Nokia USA, Nature Made Vitamins, Johns Hopkins University, ENDO Pharmaceuticals, K'NEX Construction Toys, and Visit Baltimore. The agency was recognized as a "Small Giant" by the Greater Baltimore Tech Council and was chosen as a "Best Place for Business Women to Work" by "Smart Woman Magazine."
December 12, 2013
1:00pm ET / 10:00am PT