Learning from Ben & Jerry's mistakes, you need to ask your customers what they want and then give that to them.
Let's just get the first part out of the way here. Ben & Jerry's is not eliminating e-mail marketing. Secondly, if it did, the world would go on and quite possibly the e-mail marketing industry. Of course, this noise was enough for the e-mail and social marketing space to furiously whip itself into a frenzied storm. We've heard and seen plenty of "e-mail is dead" headlines during the past decade, but this was a real live brand (and a beloved one at that) killing e-mail, and it was almost entirely misconstrued.
The U.K. operations of Ben & Jerry's announced that it would be eliminating its monthly e-mail newsletter and moving its communications to Facebook and Twitter. Americans still hungry for flavored Ben & Jerry's e-mail would not starve.
So, before we break down the moo that rocked a thousand inboxes, let's look at what Sean Greenwood of Ben & Jerry's told me when we traded e-mails about this:
"Email still plays a vital role in the Ben & Jerry's "Marketing Mix" flavor! We have a great list of fans on our Chunkmail list that we send out notes to all the time with cool offers, promotions, new flavors & more. We're the luckiest company in the world because we have the best fans. After having actual fans suggest such powerhouse flavors like Chubby Hubby, Chunky Monkey and our #1 smash hit: Cherry Garcia, (all true!) who wouldn't want to be in touch MORE with our fans. Email correspondence allows us that opportunity. Plus everyone has their favorites: even Ben and Jerry! If email as a strategic tool helps us meet the need to provide our fans with choices, you won't see us cast it aside like an empty Boston Cream Pie pint container!"
The response to this news (accurate and not) was revealing. You had people questioning how and why you should shut down the pipeline that's going to deliver the highest ROI (define) of any digital channel, some yelling who would buy ice cream because of an e-mail or Facebook post, and some that drank the Kool-Aid without digesting the pint of facts that were being assembled in a quick moving free-for-all digital cage match. Take this comment into consideration:
"I just sent a final goodbye email to my list, recommending they follow us on Facebook, Twitter, or RSS."
So, rather than pontificating about which channel is the best and wondering if Ben & Jerry's U.K. team made a smart or short-sighted decision, I think it's best to look at this from a different view:
- Ask your customers what they want: Ben & Jerry's did what many marketers dare not do. It asked its customers directly what is best for them. In this case, what are their communication preferences?
- Give your customers what they want: The missed opportunity is not listening to these preferences. Unless 100 percent of Ben & Jerry's audience said to replace e-mail with Twitter/Facebook, then it is failing its customers. This is not just for Ben & Jerry's U.K. team and customers (not to mention the social media prognosticators who failed to remove their blinders), but for anyone considering eliminating an opt-in marketing channel.
Back to that comment from the person who upon reading about Ben & Jerry's killed his e-mail list. RSS jokes aside, is it wise to close any communication avenue where your customers and prospects have expressly told you they do want you to communicate with them through this channel?
The whole e-mail vs. social fight needs to be finally put to rest and the digital savvy should plan how to combine the two for the most powerful digital communication platter that a marketer could ask for. That's assuming they want to really combine performance, measurement, and engagement, and who wouldn't, right?
CMOs may have a one-track mind (and what's on that may be based on the day or the meeting), but every digital marketer needs to "get" that each communication channel is different and so are the usages of how customers approach each one. According to new research from ExactTarget, people go to meet their favorite brands in the inbox for promotions and general updates, Facebook for entertainment, and Twitter to stay connected and "in the know."
"Consumers don't silo their engagement with brands to a single channel, instead they tend to 'layer' marketing channels on top of one another to meet their different objectives," said Morgan Stewart, principal, ExactTarget's research and education group, in a statement. Check out their subscribers, fans, and followers report for further insight into this titillating topic.
With that in mind, should you kill a channel or bring a cut and paste messaging strategy to the table for your best advocates? Or do you listen, learn, and provide relevant and valuable messaging to each customer touch point?
Chime in here to tell me what you think, who is doing this well, and if you would eliminate one channel for another?
This Year's Premier Digital Marketing Event is #CZLSF
ClickZ Live San Francisco (Aug 11-14) brings together the industry's leading practitioners and marketing strategists to deliver 4 days of educational sessions and training workshops. From Data-Driven Marketing to Social, Mobile, Display, Search and Email, this year's comprehensive agenda will help you maximize your marketing efforts and ROI. Register today!
Simms Jenkins is CEO of BrightWave Marketing, North America's leading email marketing-focused digital agency. The award-winning firm specializes in elevating email marketing and digital messaging programs that drive revenue, cut costs, and build relationships. Jenkins has led BrightWave Marketing in establishing a world-class client list including Affiliated Computer Service (A Xerox Company), Chick-fil-A, Cox Business, Phillips66, Porsche, and Southern Company. The agency was recently ranked among the fastest growing private companies by Inc. Magazine.
Jenkins was awarded the prestigious AMY 2010 Marketer of the Year from the American Marketing Association for being the top agency marketer and the Email Marketer of the Year at the Tech Marketing Awards held by the Technology Association of Georgia. Jenkins is regarded as one of the leading experts in the email marketing industry and is regularly cited by the media as such and called upon by the financial community to provide market insight and consulting.
Jenkins is the author of two definitive and highly regarded books on email marketing; The New Inbox (published in April 2013 by ClickZ/Incisive Media) and The Truth About Email Marketing (published by Pearson's Financial Times Press in 2008). Jenkins is currently the Email Marketing Best Practices Columnist for ClickZ, the largest resource of interactive marketing news and commentary in the world, online or off. His industry articles have been called one of the top 21 information sources for email marketers.
He has been featured in Fortune Magazine, The Wall Street Journal, Adweek, Bloomberg TV, Wired Magazine, and scores of other leading publications and media outlets. Jenkins is a regular speaker at major digital industry and general business conferences.
Additionally, Jenkins is the creator of EmailStatCenter.com and SocialStatCenter.com, the leading authorities on email and social media metrics. Prior to founding BrightWave Marketing, Jenkins headed the CRM group at Cox Interactive Media.
Jenkins serves on the eMarketing Association's Board of Advisors among other civic and professional boards. He is also a mentor at Flashpoint, a Georgia Tech-based startup accelerator program. Jenkins is a graduate of Denison University in Granville, Ohio and resides in Atlanta's Buckhead neighborhood with his wife and three children.
The Marketer's Guide to Customer Loyalty
Customer loyalty is imperative to success, but fostering and maintaining loyalty takes a lot of work. This guide is here to help marketers build, execute, and maintain a successful loyalty initiative.
The Multiplier Effect of Integrating Search & Social Advertising
Latest research reveals 68% higher revenue per conversion for marketers who integrate their search & social advertising. In addition to the research results, this whitepaper also outlines 5 strategies and 15 tactics you can use to better integrate your search and social campaigns.