A Community Influence Pyramid that will help you select the tool that's best for your particular situation.
There has been a lot of buzz around social influence scores as marketers, PR professionals, and even customer service teams increasingly turn to these tools to help better understand their communities and to facilitate decision-making. But not all influence tools are created equal, as they often measure different things and may even be irrelevant when it comes to a particular initiative or brand effort. So what are the major ways to measure influence and what tools are best for your needs? Well, it depends, and that's why I've developed a Community Influence Pyramid to help you select the tool that's best for your particular situation. The pyramid starts with the most basic and broadest influence measurement tools and ends with the Holy Grail - a highly customizable approach that can have you engaging with key brand advocates around an individual brand, product, or topic in the channels that are most relevant to them. Also, check out the brand relevance grade for each type of influence tool, as I scored each based on how relevant each tool may be to an individual brand's need to identify, engage, and influence the influencer.
Personal Influence Measurement Tools
The broadest and most basic of all influence measurement tools are the personal influence measurement solutions such as Klout, PeerIndex, Kred, TweetLevel, and PeekAnalytics. They serve to identify individuals, rely primarily on social networks as the source of their data, and create scores and profiles based on a particular user's activity. Many of the tools mentioned here rely on consumers to provide access via an account sign-up in order to gain access to their social profiles to calculate the influence "score." Marketers may also see these tools (e.g., a Klout score) integrated into their social campaign management solution in an effort to provide marketers and customer service departments with some additional context around individuals who may be talking about or engaging with their brand.
Brand Relevance Score: C
Contextual Influence Measurement Tools
Next up are contextual influence measurement tools, which start with content and attempt to identify and analyze the influence of individuals around a given topic and/or conversation. These tools often employ sophisticated text analytics to scrape the web around key content areas and to identify users who have created or interacted with that content. User scores are assigned to individuals around content or topic areas and can be helpful to marketers looking to reach or engage groups of users around a particular issue or brand strategy. Sample tools include mPACT Pro, TRAACKR, and Appinions. Here again, marketers may see many of these tools integrated into their social campaign management solutions.
Brand Relevance Score: B
Brand Influence and Engagement Index Scores
Taking it up a notch in both relevance and usefulness are brand influence and engagement index scores, which might be calculated via third-party tools (e.g., CalmSea) or via proprietary algorithms developed internally. These tools may leverage an API connection or feed such as Facebook Connect to look at an individual's activity and influence. Individuals are scored based on their sharing and ability to get others within their network to the brand's page/campaign or website. Scores may also be calculated around engagement by looking at the individual's likes, shares, and posts/comments, and often use recency, frequency, and the volume of each to create a score (e.g., 0 to 100). These scores are extremely relevant to identify brand advocates as they reflect activity tied directly to the brand and within the community.
Brand Relevance Score: B+
Custom/Cross-Channel Influence Scores
Looking for influence and advocacy nirvana? Well, it will probably have to be a custom solution. For the ultimate solution for finding influential individuals who can advocate for your brand around a particular topic or issue, leverage cross-channel CRM data and activity (opens, clicks, likes, comments, retweets, @mentions, etc.), third-party influence scores, brand specific influence/engagement scores, purchasing and loyalty data, and history. These solutions may also allow brands the ability to sort, weigh the individual components selected, and can also give the brand the ability to analyze and score the data to create custom scores and/or models. As a result they are also the most expensive to develop and maintain and are for the most part proprietary solutions. However, having built and seen these solutions in practice at leading Fortune 2000 brands, I can honestly say the results and use cases/applications are powerful. Imagine you're a product manager preparing a new product launch. Looking for advocates to test the product and provide feedback, query your CRM system for individuals who currently own an existing product, have opened/clicked a relevant email campaign, liked/commented/shared a relevant post on a social community, and have loyalty scores in the 90th percentile based on their points. Download the segment and begin your conversation. This is the future of building conversations with advocates around specific products or efforts and it may even change the way we as marketers think about our marketing launch and roll-out plans in general.
Brand Relevance Score: A
Given the rise, and increasing importance of social media, influence scores will no doubt be here to stay. However, what remains true for much of marketing in today's world is that the best and most accurate solutions will most certainly be customized around an individual's unique data and a brand's specific needs. For more information around influence measurement tools, check out The Realtime Report's Guide to Influence Measurement Tools, one of the more comprehensive reviews of the various influence tools on the market today.
Want to learn more?
Attend ClickZ Live New York March 30 - April 1. With over 15 years' experience delivering industry-leading events, ClickZ Live brings together over 60 expert speakers to offer an action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covering all aspects of digital marketing. Register today!
Michael Della Penna is an digital marketing veteran, entrepreneur, and visionary currently serving as CEO of Invisible Media, a next-generation mobile data, decisioning, and marketing automation platform. Prior to joining Invisible Media, Michael was the senior vice president of emerging channels at Responsys. His responsibilities included spearheading the overall strategic direction, M&A efforts (including the acquisition of PushIO), partnerships, and solution offering across key digital channels including social, mobile, and display. Before joining Responsys, Michael founded Conversa Marketing, a full-service email and social CRM agency that helped brands ignite conversations and cultivate relationships with customers across the social Web. Conversa Marketing, was acquired by StrongView in 2010. Before branching out on his own, Michael served as CMO for Epsilon. At Epsilon, Michael helped grow and transform the company from a database provider to a multi-channel marketing services powerhouse in just three years. Michael's other key leadership roles include CMO at Bigfoot Interactive, vice president of strategic development at CNET Networks, Inc., and vice president of marketing at ZDNet. Michael has been named to BtoB Magazine's 100 Most Influential People in Business-to-Business Marketing five times and received a BBA and an MBA from Hofstra University.
Singapore, 5-6 March
Bangkok, 17-18 March
Hong Kong, April 2015
A Buyer's Guide to Affiliate Management Software
Manage your performance marketing with the right solution. Choose a platform that will mutually empower advertisers and media partners!
Google My Business Listings Demystified
To help brands control how they appear online, Google has developed a new offering: Google My Business Locations. This whitepaper helps marketers understand how to use this powerful new tool.
March 24, 2015
12:00pm ET/9:00am PT