Home  › Email › Email Marketing

Case Study: Triple Your ROI With Smart List Management

  |  February 4, 2013   |  Comments

By looking at ways to mail less but earn more for each email you send, you can improve performance without fatiguing your list.

A lot of companies looking to improve their email marketing focus on creative, like subject lines and the copy, design, and/or layout in the body of the email. This isn't wrong, but there's another element you should be looking at: your list selections.

Here's a case study showing how I helped one of my clients nearly triple their ROI, taking it from $0.94 to $2.77, primarily by focusing on which lists they sent to.

This is the tale of two sends, mailed just about a month apart.


As you can see, for the first send we had one control and two test creative executions. We generated just $0.94 for each $1 we spent on the send - meaning that we lost money overall. But the control was profitable, generating $1.52 for each $1 it cost.

This is a good result; we have a profitable creative execution. In most cases you'd simply take the creative winner, develop a new test, and do another A/B split test the following month to the same lists.

But we wanted to see if we could boost performance even further with some list analysis.

Thanks to the client's data team we were able to match revenue generated back to the specific list selects.

For the first send we used nine different selects from four different lists. Here's the breakdown:


Let me take a minute to talk about list segmentation and selects. I often get asked about the best way to segment a list. There's no single answer to this question: it depends on (a) how you're going to use the list and (b) what data is available to segment by.

In this case, the client is a large organization with more than 20 business units and too many products to count. In their jargon, "list" means the source of the data. In this example:

  • List A is a list of industry names they purchase each year from a legitimate list broker.
    • The broker provides the titles (along with other data points) associated with each email address, so for this list they often segment that way.
  • List B is a list that was developed in-house by this business unit - they've collected the email addresses of purchasers as well as those who have browsed their e-commerce website while logged in.
    • While we would be able to segment this list by title, past experience has shown that it's more effective to look at engagement and recency, so we took current and previous year purchasers along with those who have explored the e-commerce site this year.
  • Lists C and D are lists that have been developed by other business units within this organization.
    • While we don't have specific titles here, we know what part of the organization these names are from (I've called it "department" here); we've also taken a small portion of List D for which there's very little data (Miscellaneous), on the off chance that, since there's little information about them, they won't be mailed much and we'll get a good response.

Going back to the grid above, you can see that only three of the nine list segments had an ROI over $1, meaning that they were profitable. The other six were not profitable.

For the second send we decided to go to only the three profitable lists. This cut our send quantity down dramatically, from more than 250,000 addresses to just over 100,000 names.


With the second send, our ROI nearly tripled. We went from earning $0.97 for each dollar spent to earning $2.77 overall - solidly profitable.

The control (which was the same as the control in the first send) saw a similar lift in ROI, from $1.52 per dollar spent to $4.10. Total revenue for the second send was 12 percent higher than for the first, even though our mail quantity was less than half the first send.


When we looked at list performance, all three lists were profitable on the second send.

And, while we were testing creative on both sends, the lifts we saw were the result of list management and selection - not of creative gains. Because the control remained the control over both sends and our test creatives could not beat it.

One more note: this type of list management helps guard against over-mailing, which can cause erosion in list performance. By looking at ways to mail less but earn more for each email you send, you can improve performance without fatiguing your list.

Until next time,



ClickZ Live New York Want to learn more? Join us at ClickZ Live New York 2015
[ALERT] Super Saver Rates Expire January 30. With over 15 years of experience delivering industry leading events, ClickZ Live brings together over 50 expert speakers to deliver an action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covering all aspects of digital marketing. Quick! - Register today to secure your place at the best rate.


Jeanne Jennings

Jeanne Jennings is one of the World's Top 50 Email Marketing Influencers (Vocus, 2014). She has more than 20 years of experience in the email and online marketing and product development world. Jeanne's direct-response approach to email strategy, tactics, and creative direction helps organizations make their email marketing initiatives more effective and more profitable. Clients include: ConsumerReports.org, FDANews, Hasbro, PRWeb, Scholastic, Verizon, and WeightWatchers. Want to learn more? Check out her blog.

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

Get ClickZ Email newsletters delivered right to your inbox. Subscribe today!




Featured White Papers

Google My Business Listings Demystified

Google My Business Listings Demystified
To help brands control how they appear online, Google has developed a new offering: Google My Business Locations. This whitepaper helps marketers understand how to use this powerful new tool.

5 Ways to Personalize Beyond the Subject Line

5 Ways to Personalize Beyond the Subject Line
82 percent of shoppers say they would buy more items from a brand if the emails they sent were more personalized. This white paper offer five tactics that will personalize your email beyond the subject line and drive real business growth.



    • E-Commerce Marketing Associate
      E-Commerce Marketing Associate (OmniVista Health) - BaltimoreOmniVista Health is looking to add an E-Commerce Marketing Associate to our expanding...
    • Front End Web Developer
      Front End Web Developer (Agora Financial) - BaltimoreAgora Financial, an independent financial publisher, has an immediate opening for a Front-End...
    • Senior Outside Sales
      Senior Outside Sales (RioSeo) - San Diego~~RioSEO is the leading provider of Local Search technology to multi-store retailers and brands. Our software...