Turn Testing into a Game: One of the Most Effective Ways to Create a Testing Culture

  |  October 29, 2013   |  Comments   |  

A step-by-step guide on how to get colleagues within your organization excited about testing marketing creatives.

I have spent 5 years trying to convince clients to test and what I have learned is that creating a testing culture is a grassroots movement. It doesn’t happen from a company-wide memo and it simply can’t exist or be sustainable until everyone begins to adopt a mindset of continuous optimization.

A company may have any number of reasons why they aren’t testing, but often I find one underlying issue that you’ll need to overcome: Everyone is wrong some of the time.

Why do we hate to test? Because it hurts when we’re wrong. And let’s face it; our bosses are paying for our expertise, and for wins. Unfortunately, testing proves or disproves a hypothesis. Sure, you can drastically reduce the risk of being wrong with the more research and effort that goes into each hypothesis, but the risk is always there, and sometimes the bottom–line is that you’re going to lose.

Hey! Losing (sometimes) is okay. Yep, I said it: losing sometimes is okay. It doesn’t mean you’re a failure or bad at your job. It means there's something else going on that you’ll need to discover. No one on earth can be right all the time, and it’s better to make a smart marketing decision (win or lose) than a blind one where you just sit back and hope for the best.

The secret is to make a game out of it. One of the most effective ways that I have found to create a testing culture is to make a game out of it. An example of one site doing just that is www.whichtestwon.com. People love to play “guess the winner”, and the results of the game can help reinforce that we’re not always right in our assumptions about our visitors.

Using this concept, I created a way for my clients to do this within their organizations. It didn’t just act as a good promotional tool, but also engaged different people in the company that wouldn’t have otherwise seen our testing efforts.

How you can get started:

The bad news is there isn’t a ready-made solution (or at least I haven’t found it) out there to do what I’m about to describe. However, if you have a good developer, the tool isn’t that hard to create and has provided a great deal of benefit within my optimization programs.

1. Send an email out within your organization when a new test goes live. This should describe what you’re testing, provide a link to where your voting platform is set up and encourage your recipients to vote on the creative they think will win. Be sure to set up the right access levels to protect any information that may be confidential.

Tip: If you’re having a hard time getting users to engage with your voting platform, try an incentive. A $25 Amazon gift card or free lunch to someone who voted correctly is a nice reward for three minutes of their time.

2. Have a voting platform that houses your background information, what you’re testing and provides a way for users to vote for the creative they believe will win. If you do take advantage of the incentive, make sure to provide a field for users to identify themselves before they vote.

3. Once they have voted, thank them for playing and let them know that you’ll follow up with the results once the test has finished. The confirmation page should also provide the following:

  • The current voting results. I would encourage you to show percentages instead of raw numbers to avoid displaying low activity in the beginning of a test.
  • Give users a chance to comment. If possible, allow your users to comment on the different creatives. This will encourage involvement and hopefully create a competitive, yet collaborative environment.

4. Send them an email once your test has ended with the results (and winner of your Amazon gift card if you offered an incentive). This step is crucial because it’s where your colleagues’ thoughts and beliefs are challenged. Along with the winning creative, be sure to share the possible impact the test could have on the bottom-line of the business. At this point, it stops being a “my thoughts against yours” argument, and allows your customers a voice. This is the power of testing.

How to go above and beyond:

The voting platform should engage your organization, but it will also become an optimization archive that you can refer back to. If you want to take this concept a step further, I would suggest setting up a dashboard section that monitors the program’s success and allows users easy access to past tests and insights.

Once you have shown your colleagues that it’s okay to lose, show them how to win.

Just because it’s okay to lose sometimes, doesn’t mean you should be aimlessly testing your ideas. After you have broken down the emotional barrier of failure (my new favorite saying), show your colleagues how they can begin crafting good hypotheses with qualitative and quantitative data directly from your customers.

Remember, a good idea can come from anywhere, but first you’ll need to show your colleagues the power of testing, that it’s okay to be wrong, and then how to create good hypotheses that are worth testing on your customers.

Image on home page via Shutterstock.

Subscribe to ClickZ Asia to receive your weekly dose of the region's latest trends, tips, and insights straight to your inbox.

ClickZ Live New York Want to learn more? Join us at ClickZ Live New York 2015
[ALERT] Super Saver Rates Expire January 30. With over 15 years of experience delivering industry leading events, ClickZ Live brings together over 50 expert speakers to deliver an action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covering all aspects of digital marketing. Quick! - Register today to secure your place at the best rate.


Breanne Maliniak

Breanne Maliniak is a user experience and conversion rate optimization consultant. With over 5 years of experience in the digital space, her passion is balancing business and consumer needs to improve her clients’ profitability. With years of consulting for clients of all sizes in B2B and B2C industries, she firmly believes that a company’s success relies on happy customers and works on helping organizations discover and connect user experience to every facet of their business. By doing extensive research, Breanne’s passion for creating targeted data-driven optimization strategies has led to successful projects with marquee clients such as SAP, Four Seasons Hotels & Resorts, Yves Saint Laurent, Hewlett-Packard and Aberdeen Asset Management. In 2010, Breanne was recognized with the HSMAI Adrian Award for the Best Search Marketing Strategy.

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

Get the ClickZ Analytics newsletter delivered to you. Subscribe today!



Featured White Papers

Google My Business Listings Demystified

Google My Business Listings Demystified
To help brands control how they appear online, Google has developed a new offering: Google My Business Locations. This whitepaper helps marketers understand how to use this powerful new tool.

5 Ways to Personalize Beyond the Subject Line

5 Ways to Personalize Beyond the Subject Line
82 percent of shoppers say they would buy more items from a brand if the emails they sent were more personalized. This white paper offer five tactics that will personalize your email beyond the subject line and drive real business growth.



    • E-Commerce Marketing Associate
      E-Commerce Marketing Associate (OmniVista Health) - BaltimoreOmniVista Health is looking to add an E-Commerce Marketing Associate to our expanding...
    • Front End Web Developer
      Front End Web Developer (Agora Financial) - BaltimoreAgora Financial, an independent financial publisher, has an immediate opening for a Front-End...
    • Senior Outside Sales
      Senior Outside Sales (RioSeo) - San Diego~~RioSEO is the leading provider of Local Search technology to multi-store retailers and brands. Our software...