Traditional newspapers' inability to thrive online costs them dearly, a new study finds.
Online classifieds site Craigslist costs the Bay Area's traditional newspapers, and their online divisions, between $50 and $65 million annually in revenues from employment ads alone, according to a report by Bob Cauthorn, former digital media VP at SFGate.com, the site for the San Francisco Chronicle.
Cauthorn put together the report, part of a package called "Competing with Craig," for research group Classified Intelligence. While Cauthorn didn't reveal the details of his methodology, he said he estimates the average recruitment ad in a metro daily would be worth $700. Craigslist charges $75.
"Craig is pulling out of this market alone somewhere north of $7 million to $8 million dollars, and probably closer to $10," said Cauthorn. "That's for recruitment alone."
In the report, Cauthorn says Bay Area newspaper executives can only blame themselves for losing their leadership position, "because they took no action and listened instead to the arguments inspired by fear, lack of vision, and short-sighted greed."
According to the study, Craigslist had 12,200 active job listings on its San Francisco site the week of November 21, 2004. In contrast, the San Francisco Chronicle had 1,500; the Oakland Tribune had 734; the San Jose Mercury News had an estimated 1,700; and the Contra Costa Times had around 1,000.
Cauthorn suggests that to compete with Craigslist, newspapers should begin offering free online classifieds, and promote the offer in their print publications. They should also offer easy, self-service tools to let users post ads online, and include anonymous Craigslist-style email aliases.
One advantage newspapers have, the study says, is businesses find it easier to work with them than with Craigslist. Cauthorn also points to Craigslist's customer support structure as an area of weakness.
"It's not a fatal flaw, and Craigslist will certainly work it out," Cauthorn writes. "But this problem, and Craigslist's weakness in dealing with institutional customers, provide enough of a gap for other smart publishers to flood the gap while Craigslist sorts itself out."
In another section of the package, 23-year-old Craigslist user Avi Zollman also offers suggestions for traditional newspapers' online divisions: provide RSS feeds of listings, post ads immediately, and let users have all the space they need, including for photos.
"Obviously they have to reach a younger audience, whether it's going to be in the newspaper or in RSS feeds sent to wireless devices with new forms of classified ads," said Peter Zollman, founding principal of Classified Intelligence and father of Craigslist user Avi. "The short answer is that it's going to have to be all of those if they want to stay in the business."
Want to learn more?
Attend ClickZ Live New York March 30 - April 1. With over 15 years' experience delivering industry-leading events, ClickZ Live brings together over 60 expert speakers to offer an action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covering all aspects of digital marketing. Register today!
Pamela Parker is a former managing editor of ClickZ News, Features, and Experts. She's been covering interactive advertising and marketing since the boom days of 1999, chronicling the dot-com crash and the subsequent rise of the medium. Before working at ClickZ, Parker was associate editor at @NY, a pioneering Web site and e-mail newsletter covering New York new media start-ups. Parker received a master's degree in journalism, with a concentration in new media, from Columbia University's Graduate School of Journalism.
Singapore, 5-6 March
Bangkok, 17-18 March
Hong Kong, April 2015
A Buyer's Guide to Affiliate Management Software
Manage your performance marketing with the right solution. Choose a platform that will mutually empower advertisers and media partners!
Google My Business Listings Demystified
To help brands control how they appear online, Google has developed a new offering: Google My Business Locations. This whitepaper helps marketers understand how to use this powerful new tool.
March 24, 2015
12:00pm ET/9:00am PT