Members of the E-mail Service Provider Coalition (ESPC) left Microsoft's headquarters pleased, after meeting with leading mail transfer agents (MTA), reputation and seal providers, and anti-spam vendors at a summit on the Sender ID Framework.
"It was a real show of consensus and force around authenticated email," said Trevor Hughes, executive director of the ESPC. "We have come away from the event feeling like it was a great success."
Sender ID, the convergence of Microsoft's Caller ID for email proposal and Meng Wong's Sender Policy Framework (SPF), verifies that each email message originates from the Internet domain it claims to come from based on the sending server's IP address. Eliminating domain spoofing will help legitimate senders protect their domain names and reputations, and help recipients more effectively identify and filter junk email.
Sender ID is currently being evaluated by the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) as an industry standard for email authentication. A final draft of the specification could be delivered when the IETF meets in two weeks.
According to Hughes, the event began with a high-level discussion of the spam environment, which led to a discussion of SPF by its author, Meng Wong. Microsoft then led a discussion of the Sender ID spec in detail. Then ISP, MTA, and anti-spam vendors discussed how they would implement Sender ID in their products or services.
"It was compelling to see five CEOs on a panel from leading organizations in the anti-spam and MTA email space talking about the fact that this is a train that's already left the station, and that we just need to make sure that it keeps chugging along. To hear how enthusiastic they were and how willing they were to make sure their pieces of the puzzle were going to work in a Sender ID environment was really encouraging," Hughes said.
Rather than being a one-way presentation from Microsoft, there was a good two-way discussion, according to Stephen Guerra, director of deliverability and ISP relations for ESPC member Silverpop.
"We were able to offer them some good feedback, and they were very receptive of that. It wasn't just Microsoft saying 'this is how things are going to be'. We gave them some significant feedback and even proposed solutions for some of these issues," Guerra said.
Microsoft is recommending that email senders begin publishing their records in the SPF format by October 1, which many senders have already done. Microsoft is suggesting that email receiving organizations fully implement the checks for the Sender ID protocol by December 31. This should be a very reasonable timeline, Guerra said.
"The challenge for Sender ID is really not going to be implementing it on the ESP side," he said. "What's probably going to be the biggest challenge for ESPC members is working with their clients, making sure this information is being published in their records appropriately."
Sender ID requires that information about a sender's authorized IP addresses be published in the DNS records of the domain that is responsible for the message being sent. If a marketing email is sent from a client's domain, ESPs like Silverpop will either have to control that domain themselves, or work with the client's IT departments to make sure the ESP's servers are published as authorized senders in their DNS records.
A bigger challenge facing the email industry as a whole is educating those that are unaware that these changes are going to affect them, Guerra said. While a lot of focus has been put on email marketing, senders of transactional emails or just regular corporate email senders may be caught unaware if they are not addressing these protocols.
"Some corporate servers are going to find that their corporate mail will become harder to get through in the next few months if they're not adding this to their outgoing messages and their DNS records," he said. "A recurring topic at summit was that the ESP industry as a whole needs to step up and educate the email industry in general about Sender ID and the other authentication protocols that are coming."
"This is a big first step, but it is not a silver bullet," Hughes said. "I would hope that people would not look at their inboxes in January and see just as much spam as they had in December and decide Sender ID is a failure. I think that would be entirely the wrong metric."
What Sender ID will do is address phishing -- scams which attempt to trick users into divulging sensitive information, such as credit card numbers or account passwords, by pretending to be from a legitimate source, and spoofing -- sending email purporting to be from someone it's not.
"It's also going to let legitimate senders stand up and be recognized; to be held accountable for their sending practices, and also be rewarded for good sending practices," Hughes said.
While complying with Sender ID will not guarantee that mail will reach the intended inbox or avoid filtering, what it may do is give the message a better chance of getting through.
"That deliverability message is really important to the legitimate email industry. Even the fact that it will be a consideration in weighing whether something gets into the inbox is a significant step forward in terms of deliverability," Hughes said. "What I envision, and would expect in the next 12 months, is a day in which legitimate senders are authenticating all of their email, and it is routinely being whitelisted and delivered directly into the inbox."
That way, if someone violates the expectations of the subscriber, they can be held accountable, because now their identity is known. In addition, a whitelist of legitimate email senders will allow ISPs to be more aggressive in labeling suspect messages as spam.
"Filtering is really good for 90 percent of spam, but once you try to get that last 10 percent, you start hitting false positives that become problematic. This is going to allow ISPs to have much greater confidence in filtering that last 10 percent of spam," Hughes said.
Last Week to Save on SES London Tickets!
SES London takes place February 10-13, 2014. Learn to engage customers and increase ROI by distributing your online marketing efforts across paid, owned & earned media. Join the leaders of today's digital marketing & advertising industry. Find out more ››
*Saver Rates expire this Friday, Dec 13.
Kevin Newcomb joined ClickZ in August 2004, covering search marketing and other online marketing topics. He has been reporting on web-based businesses since 2000.
Before the bubble burst, Kevin was a marketing manager for an online computer reseller, handling copywriting, e-mail marketing, search marketing and running the affiliate program.
With a combination of real-world marketing experience and years of business journalism, Kevin brings to ClickZ a unique ability to deliver news and training materials that help online marketers do their jobs better.
December 12, 2013
1:00pm ET / 10:00am PT