Judge Downs Pop-Ups in Contrary Decision

  |  December 23, 2003   |  Comments

A judge grants a preliminary injunction against adware company WhenU's pop-ups.

Bucking decisions made in two earlier cases, a U.S. District Judge this week enjoined New York adware company WhenU from popping up a competitor's ads over plaintiff 1-800 Contacts' Web site.

Saying users of WhenU's desktop software might be confused about the source of the pop-up ads, New York District Judge Deborah A. Batts said the adware firm could no longer display Vision Direct's ads over its competitor's site. Vision Direct is WhenU's client and a co-defendant in the lawsuit.

"Essentially we're pleased that the judge dismissed the copyright claims and disappointed that it was a split decision on the trademark," said Avi Naidern, CEO of WhenU. "There have been two judges that have already ruled that there is no use of a competitor's trademark when you target advertising this way. We're confident the ruling will be overturned on appeal."

Naidern said if the decision is not overturned, it could have far-reaching implications for search engine advertising.

"If this judge is deemed to be correct this will create major problems for search engine marketing in general on the Internet," Naidern said. "Using names of companies to target advertising is a fundamental part of advertising."

In October 2002, 1-800 Contacts sued WhenU and VisionDirect in New York over ads that appeared when users went to 1800contacts.com. 1-800 Contacts alleged that WhenU deliberately targeted offers from rivals based on the Web site that its users were visiting, and hence, the suit claimed, Vision Direct profited from its competitor's brand equity. The plaintiff relied on trademark and copyright law, and alleged that consumers don't realize they are seeing pop-up ads delivered by WhenU's software when they visit the 1800contacts.com site.

The New York judge granted 1-800 Contact's injunction based on trademark infringement.

"WhenU claimed there was no likelihood of confusion on the part of consumers because they had a disclaimer on the ad that said it was from WhenU, not the Web site where it appeared. The court rejected that argument and found it was likely that consumers would be confused," said Terence Ross of New York-based Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, the law firm that represented 1-800 Contacts.

Other judges haven't agreed with Judge Batts' preliminary conclusions. On Nov. 19, a Detroit judge presiding over a similar lawsuit brought by Wells Fargo against WhenU ruled to the contrary, saying consumers were not likely to be confused by the source of the ads.

A similar case filed by U-Haul against WhenU around the same time as the 1-800 Contacts case went in WhenU's favor, too. U.S. District Court Judge Gerald Lee granted WhenU's motion to dismiss the meat of the charges brought against it by U-Haul.

"That case has been appealed to the United States Court of Appeals," Ross noted.

Ross was also involved in a case against adware maker Gator and a group of publishers including the New York Times Co. that was settled in February. A preliminary injunction had been issued against Gator. The companies settled on the eve of trial.

"That's the same court where the first WhenU case was. Different judges in the same court came to different conclusions. That points out that this is a novel area of the law that involves tricky applications of intellectual property law. You have two judges in the same court coming to opposite decisions and a judge in New York and one in Michigan coming to opposite decisions," said Ross.

"Ultimately the Supreme Court will have to take one of these cases and resolve the differences. But that will be a couple of years from now," he said.

ClickZ Live Toronto Twitter Canada MD Kirstine Stewart to Keynote Toronto
ClickZ Live Toronto (May 14-16) is a new event addressing the rapidly changing landscape that digital marketers face. The agenda focuses on customer engagement and attaining maximum ROI through online marketing efforts across paid, owned & earned media. Register now and save!*
*Early Bird Rates expire April 17.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Janis Mara

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

ClickZ Today is our #1 newsletter.
Get a daily dose of digital marketing.

COMMENTS

UPCOMING EVENTS

Featured White Papers

ion Interactive Marketing Apps for Landing Pages White Paper

Marketing Apps for Landing Pages White Paper
Marketing apps can elevate a formulaic landing page into a highly interactive user experience. Learn how to turn your static content into exciting marketing apps.

eMarketer: Redefining Mobile-Only Users: Millions Selectively Avoid the Desktop

Redefining 'Mobile-Only' Users: Millions Selectively Avoid the Desktop
A new breed of selective mobile-only consumers has emerged. What are the demos of these users and how and where can marketers reach them?

Jobs

    • Contact Center Professional
      Contact Center Professional (TCC: The Contact Center) - Hunt ValleyLooking to join a workforce that prides themselves on being routine and keeping...
    • Recruitment and Team Building Ambassador
      Recruitment and Team Building Ambassador (Agora Inc.) - BaltimoreAgora, www.agora-inc.com, continues to expand! In order to meet the needs of our...
    • Design and Publishing Specialist
      Design and Publishing Specialist (Bonner and Partners) - BaltimoreIf you’re a hungry self-starter, creative, organized and have an extreme...