Home  › Marketing › Strategies

Device Fingerprinting Raises Privacy Fears

  |  March 21, 2011   |  Comments

Technology may become new focal point for concerns over consumer data privacy.

fingerprintingPrivacy advocates have expressed concern about device fingerprinting, an emerging technology that allows advertisers to uniquely and persistently identify connected devices such as computers, smartphones, and tablets.

When sending or receiving data, connected devices transmit pieces of information about their properties and settings, which can be collected and pieced together to form a unique, persistent "fingerprint" for that specific device.

Once a device has been assigned a fingerprint, advertisers can use that ID to track its behavior as it moves across the web, providing similar functionality to a cookie. The strength of a fingerprint, however, is that it tracks the device itself rather than the cookie placed on it, meaning it cannot be deleted or lost, and can - in theory - remain consistent for the life of a device.

This characteristic has led some to deem the technology a more significant threat to user privacy than cookie-based tracking, since a user cannot choose to delete their fingerprint as they can with cookies.

"You don't have any control over them, or at least not the same kind of control you do over cookies… That makes fingerprinting a serious privacy threat," said Peter Eckersley, senior staff technologist for the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

Eckersley said the persistence of fingerprints could lead to more detailed behavioral profiles being tied to a device over time. "If it becomes standard practice for sites to use fingerprints, a universal record of everything you look at could be created. It's really important to prevent that from happening."

But the providers of fingerprint technology - most prominently BlueCava and Ringleader Digital - claim it improves on cookies in one crucial area: keeping users opted out. Cookie-based opt-outs are fundamentally flawed because when a user deletes her cookies or switches to another browser, she is effectively opted back in to ad tracking.

BlueCava CEO David Norris said his company allows users to opt out of fingerprint tracking and targeting for the life of a device with a single action. Once a user decides to opt a device out, BlueCava says it will simply ignore its unique fingerprint every time the company comes into contact with it.

Meanwhile Ringleader Digital CEO Bob Walczak said his company has gone a step further - assigning a dedicated opt-out fingerprint to devices through which that preference has been expressed. In theory therefore, the company cannot extract information from that device other than the fact that it has opted out.

As FTC and congressional scrutiny of online tracking continues, device fingerprinting looks set to become a more prominent issue.

Late last year the FTC issued a report calling for a "do-not-track" mechanism for digital devices. Although the majority of discussion around the issue has centered on tracking through desktop browsers, the FTC stressed its concerns apply equally to mobile.

"The FTC invited comment on how [do-not-track] could be implemented in the mobile context and we expect to address these issues in the final report," a spokesperson told ClickZ.

BlueCava's Norris said his firm's technology is do-not-track ready. All that's required is for browser manufacturers to implement solutions through which users can demonstrate their preference.

"As soon as browsers support do-not-track we will honor that choice," he said. "Cookies are old, our ability to offer opt-out is superior."

The EFF's Eckersley believes do-not-track is a less-than-ideal way to accommodate user choice but acknowledged its expediency from a policy standpoint.

"We're going to need a combination of technology and policy for it to succeed. From the policy side, do-not-track is the best option," he said.

He argued regulatory intervention is necessary to halt an "arms race" between users and ad trackers. "The trackers are always going to win. They have many more engineers working on these technologies," he said.


Jack Marshall

Jack Marshall was a staff writer and stats editor for ClickZ News from 2007 until August 2011. 

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

Get the ClickZ Marketing newsletter delivered to you. Subscribe today!



Featured White Papers

2015 Holiday Email Guide

2015 Holiday Email Guide
The holidays are just around the corner. Download this whitepaper to find out how to create successful holiday email campaigns that drive engagement and revenue.

Three Ways to Make Your Big Data More Valuable

Three Ways to Make Your Big Data More Valuable
Big data holds a lot of promise for marketers, but are marketers ready to make the most of it to drive better business decisions and improve ROI? This study looks at the hidden challenges modern marketers face when trying to put big data to use.