Privacy Advocates: Facebook Changes Are ’Superficial’

  |  May 27, 2010   |  Comments

Nine organizations bash Facebook’s privacy tweaks, while acknowledging CEO Mark Zuckerberg took a minor positive step.

Privacy and consumer advocates have a response to the policy tweaks announced by Facebook yesterday: Nice try, Zuckerberg. But not nearly good enough.

Such was the collective disposition during a 30-minute teleconference attended by nine organizations and a mix of major general circulation and business publications on Thursday afternoon. The advocates characterized Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s newest privacy-related announcements as nothing more than strategically preemptive moves to distract the FTC and Congress from taking a hard line on data issues. They complained about too many default settings remaining opt-in instead of being changed to opt-out - particularly the Instant Personalization program.

The same critics did concede that the privacy control simplifications were a step in the right direction. But they say that Facebook’s real intent has little to do with privacy concerns and a lot to do with the monetization of user data. And they pointed to the similarities between what’s happened in the last month to the way the Beacon controversy unfolded as a material reason for such skepticism.

Here are a handful of their more interesting comments:

John Simpson, privacy advocate with Consumer Watchdog:

"I think this whole process shows a...mindset that Facebook follows and Google follows. And that’s that you push the envelope as far as you can. You grab whatever data you can. And then if there’s push-back, you then change back and do something else. It’s an operating mode of, ’Never ask permission - you can always ask for forgiveness.’ If they were sincere about privacy, the default mode for everything would be the minimal amount of sharing and if you wish to share more, you opt in to doing that. I don’t think we have any reason now to trust the company based on their past record."

Jeff Chester, co-founder of the Center for Digital Democracy:

"It took this unprecedented cross-Atlantic pressure - policy pressure - to get Facebook to change. These were positive changes that were made under the duress. They are simpler controls, but much more is needed...What Facebook has done is consciously create an architecture to encourage the transmission of user data so that it can be mined for advertising purposes without the user understanding the process."

Robert Ellis Smith, publisher of Privacy Journal:

"I was struck by the process of all of this. First of all, Mark Zuckerberg said in his comments yesterday that this was hurriedly put together...two weeks of caffeine and all-night sessions - very collegiate. But you wonder if that’s the proper atmosphere for developing a serious privacy policy. And then to compound that, he says he hopes they can now put privacy on the shelf and this will be the end of it... Most people know that to develop a privacy policy you have to keep track of new technology, and you have to update constantly. I was struck that a company that exploits and benefits so much from new technology seems to think that privacy ought to be stagnant."

Chip Pitts, president of the Bill of Rights Defense Committee and a professor at Stanford Law School:

"We shouldn’t lose sight of the fact that despite the procedural improvements made as a result of Facebook’s new approach to privacy, the substance does remain largely unchanged in terms of the default settings. Until the users’ control over their own information is truly fully realized - and that’s what is at issue here in an ongoing basis - there are still substantial questions about the deceptiveness to Facebook’s approach to these issues."

Paul Stephens, director of policy and advocacy for the Privacy Rights Clearinghouse:

"Certainly, Facebook has taken a step in the right direction in terms of simplifying things. However, we do regard the changes as largely superficial... We are particularly troubled by the default settings and by the largely opt-out approach. We view much of what has been done as a preemptive strike against regulation by the Federal Trade Commission."

Follow Christopher Heine on Twitter at @ChrisClickZ.

ClickZ Live New York Want to learn more?
Attend ClickZ Live New York March 30 - April 1. With over 15 years' experience delivering industry-leading events, ClickZ Live brings together over 60 expert speakers to offer an action-packed, educationally-focused agenda covering all aspects of digital marketing. Register today!


Christopher Heine

Christopher Heine was a senior writer for ClickZ through June 2012. He covered social media, sports/entertainment marketing, retail, and more. Heine's work has also appeared via Mashable, Brandweek, DM News, MarketingSherpa, and other tech- and ad-centric publications. USA Today, Bloomberg Radio, and The Los Angeles Times have cited him as an expert journalist.

COMMENTSCommenting policy

comments powered by Disqus

ClickZ Today is our #1 newsletter.
Get a daily dose of digital marketing.




Featured White Papers

A Buyer's Guide to Affiliate Management Software

A Buyer's Guide to Affiliate Management Software
Manage your performance marketing with the right solution. Choose a platform that will mutually empower advertisers and media partners!

Google My Business Listings Demystified

Google My Business Listings Demystified
To help brands control how they appear online, Google has developed a new offering: Google My Business Locations. This whitepaper helps marketers understand how to use this powerful new tool.


    • Website Optimizer - SEO, CRO, Analytics
      Website Optimizer - SEO, CRO, Analytics (Marcel Digital) - ChicagoMarcel Digital, an award winning interactive marketing agency established in 2003...
    • Director of Marketing
      Director of Marketing (Patron Technology) - New YorkDirector of Marketing We are seeking a Director of Marketing to manage and build our marketing...
    • Senior Interactive Producer
      Senior Interactive Producer (Ready Set Rocket) - New YorkWhat You'll Do As a member of our team, the Senior Producer reports directly to our...