Practitioners of SEO (define) talk a lot about the signals search engines use to determine whether one page or site is more relevant than another. Although this topic is rarely discussed with respect to paid search, it should be considered when planning and executing your own search campaigns as well as when evaluating your competitors’ campaigns. By understanding relevance all the way through the search experience — from the moment the searcher starts filling out that search box till the time she leaves your site (assuming she got there at all) — you can put yourself in the shoes of both the search engine and the consumer.
Search engines care a lot about the consumer experience and have editorial policies in place to set a baseline for ad relevance, as well as algorithms that use signals to determine if the ad is in fact relevant to the search query. Failure to be relevant can have devastating consequences in paid search. You might think that you are getting free branding if your ads are not clicked or your landing pages hawk a solution that doesn’t match the keyword. However, Google, Yahoo, and Microsoft all have their own versions of the Quality Score assigned to ad-keyword combinations as well as at the ad group, campaign, or account level.
Today, let’s look at some signals the search engines probably — or definitely — use to determine the relevance of your paid search ads for specific search queries.
Normalized Predicted Click-Through Rate
Obviously, ads with high positions are more likely to get the highest CTR (define), but the search engines need to grade, compare, and score ads on a level playing field. So they use various normalization tables and formulas to normalize your predicted CTR. In one of Google’s iterations to its Quality Score formula (which isn’t shared publicly), Google announced that it calculates a new Quality Score for ads on a query-by-query basis. To illustrate this fact:
- Log into your Google AdWords account, and drill down to the keyword level within an AdGroup that contains broad match keywords.
- On the right side, above the graph, is a “Filter and Views” pull-down menu. Select this pull-down and select “Segment by search terms match type” to see the CTR and other data by match type.
You’ll see that the position of your ad is often higher on exact match than phrase or broad match. This is because your ad is more relevant for that exact query.
Keyword Use in the Ad
One reason exact match CTRs are high is that a well-crafted AdGroup makes use of the exact match term in the ad creative, reinforcing the searcher’s belief that she have found a good match. Search engines may simply rely on historical CTR data (which bakes in the benefit of keyword use in the ad) or attribute an even higher score to well-crafted ads.
Domain Affinity to the Search Audience
Does your domain name have brand value? I certainly hope so, because your predicted CTR is higher when your brand both is recognized and has an affinity to the keyword. So big brands get a leg up here. But a descriptive domain or prefix to a domain can help the CTR, and then you can factor in either directly or perhaps as a signaling data point for the engines.
Click-Back Rate or Bounce Rate
Engines know that consumers unsatisfied with a landing page or site often click back to the SERP (define). So do whatever you can to engage consumers on your site. It’s win-win.
Landing Page Triggers
Google has listed the landing page as a factor in its Quality Score algorithm for some time. Unless your landing pages are heavy in rich media, it makes sense for you to include body copy that resonates with your ad.
If the search engine toolbar policies permit the use of aggregated data or if the search engines were to buy data from large panel-based research firms, the search engines could add further signals to their relevance scores. For example:
- Site engagement: Is your site sticky?
- Transition percentage to secure mode: Did consumers start a shopping or information exchange transition?
- Visits to a success page (“thank you” or “contact us” page): Pages of your site may be categorized and classified based on keyword, semantic, and behavioral use.
It’s in your best interest to optimize around these relevance score drivers regardless of whether search engines are paying attention or not. When you construct and optimize campaigns, think about relevance and all the ways it can be measured and optimized. Your bottom line will grow right along with your ad relevance.
What do you need to know about real-time bidding (RTB) to start using it? Join us on Thursday, October 15, 2009, at 1 p.m., for a free Webinar on the basics of real-time bidding to help advertisers and their agencies understand RTB’s capabilities and advantages.
Google has introduced new tools and features to AdWords to specifically address the consumer shift towards mobile.
Over the past couple of weeks, Google has been spotted introducing some interesting changes to the look and layout of its search ... read more
Today it was announced that the BBC Food recipe website is to close, or at least mothballed in some way. It contains ... read more