Learn how to improve your newsletter by seeing what other readers do with theirs. In coming weeks, I’ll present a brief analysis of newsletters you submit, using the evaluation criteria I outlined last time. I promise to be kind as I share your newsletters with the world, and to provide concrete advice you and other readers can immediately integrate into future editions.
First up is a B2C newsletter from Ohio’s Chapel Hill Mall. This newsletter receives 19.5 stars on rating of 20. Marti, the creative director, and her team at MC2 Mall Communications who produce the newsletter, have done a great job.
Strategy: 3 out of 5 stars
Marti scores high in this category because not only does she have a clear idea of what she wants to achieve with the newsletter, she’s designed a newsletter program that’s tightly integrated with the mall’s other marketing efforts. In addition to a well-defined strategic objective, the newsletter builds a community of shoppers and potential customers. Through this community, it increases awareness of and drives traffic to participating stores.
The newsletter has the same look and feel as the mall’s Web site, which helps build brand identity. Throughout the year, there are various promotions within the newsletter, such as this very cool “Fashions for the Perfect Prom” where high school juniors and seniors (and their parents) had the opportunity to create a perfect look for their special night. I spent several minutes playing around with this — it’s a blast! The important point is the Mall had radio spots to promote the event, which in turn drove traffic to the Web site, the newsletter, and ultimately, into the stores. Overall, a very integrated campaign that reached an extremely important customer segment.
List Segmentation: 3 out of 5 stars
Again, Marti and her crew are doing a great job. As people sign up for the newsletter at the Mall, they’re categorized by interest levels such as women’s fashion, men’s fashion, mall events, or new stores, to name a few. A man, for instance, receives promotions from men’s clothing stores. The group did a great job getting shoppers to sign up for the newsletter. They offered a $50 gift certificate to the information booth worker who got the most sign-ups over a month.
Content & Audience: 3 out of 5 stars
Yet another high rating. Newsletters are sent with a “Dear Kathy” salutation. The subject line is “myChapel Hill Mall News…” The newsletter contains highly targeted buckets of news and activities to address the various segments, such as the prom promotion for teens mentioned above. Other examples include articles for the Stroller Club (women with young children) and senior citizen announcements.
Permission and Privacy: 4 out of 5 stars
People can sign up for the newsletter either at the mall or on its Web site. Clear options on the front page explain how to unsubscribe or update profiles. The privacy statement is clearly visible. In the same area are options to forward the newsletter to a friend, a great way to build a subscriber list. One suggestion I’d offer is to make the link back to the Mall’s site more predominant on the newsletter. It’s a little difficult to find.
Metrics: 2.5 out of 5 stars
Marti is doing a good job in that she’s tested various elements (longer newsletters, and a text-only newsletter, which was a self-described “flop.” But kudos for trying!). She tries to build landing pages for each article to track who’s interested in what kind of information. Marti admits she’s evolving her use of metrics and would like to work toward understanding how each subscriber uses the content sent to them. Marti and her team understand content and readership are important metrics in any newsletter campaign.
Look & Feel: 4 out of 5 Stars
Four stars for a great layout with all the requisite elements. It’s informative, educational and above all entertaining. Graphics are intriguing and integrated with other marketing programs. The one concern is there does not appear to be an archive system. That’s understandable to a degree. After all, you don’t want people using outdated coupons. Yet it would be fun to be able to get back to the Prom promotion, or to view the Pet Contest winners. I’d suggest adding an archive to keep the interactivity level high.
What’s your newsletter taught you? Share it with me.
It's easy to think of customers as fish you can bait with discounts. It's also lazy. Marketers should adopt the B2B mentality of solving customers' problems.
Amazon is well-known for sending emails just for you. But a business doesn't have to be Amazon-sized to successfully deploy the same strategy.
Instead of launching a fully-formed new program, try innovating in increments, where you make a series of small changes that eventually add up to something big.
Toy retailer The Entertainer recently reported some impressive figures, including 120% growth in mobile sales and a tripling of its email revenue. ... read more