More NewsDuelling E-Mail Visions in SF

Duelling E-Mail Visions in SF

A rollicking debate ensued when the Electronic Frontier Foundation put Esther Dyson (she of the pro-sender-pays editorial ), Danny O'Brien and Mitch Kapor on stage at the Roxie Theater last night

A rollicking debate ensued when the Electronic Frontier Foundation put Esther Dyson (she of the pro-sender-pays editorial), Danny O’Brien and Mitch Kapor on stage at the Roxie Theater last night. Folks like Goodmail CEO Richard Gingras and e-mail pioneer Dave Crocker were in attendance, along with a pretty engaged crowd.

While the topic was almost certainly prompted by the AOL/Goodmail controversy, the debate was more theoretical, about whether a system in which the sender pays makes sense for e-mail. To make it brief, Dyson’s point (which I tend to agree with) is that we should try anything and everything that seems to hold the promise of stopping the spam problem, and market forces will correct the system should things go wrong. O’Brien’s main argument revolved around a few ideas: making people pay contributes to the digital divide; an “artificial market” creates perverse incentives (ISPs would have no incentive to develop their own anti-spam systems if they’re making money from the likes of Goodmail); and that market forces can’t necessarily work their magic in an environment where people have a high cost of switching ISPs (giving up their e-mail addresses). I’m sure I’m leaving something out here, but you get the gist.

All in all, a very satisfying and interesting debate. Considering the lengths to which anti-AOL/Goodmail activists have gone (accusing AOL of lying and deliberately blocking legitimate e-mail), I was surprised, but pleased, that it was so cordial and thought-provoking.

Related Articles

GDPR: The role of technology in data compliance

Data & Analytics GDPR: The role of technology in data compliance

3w Clark Boyd
What companies can learn from the We-Vibe lawsuit about the Internet of Things

Legal & Regulatory What companies can learn from the We-Vibe lawsuit about the Internet of Things

8m Al Roberts
Has advertising arrived on Google Home?

Media Has advertising arrived on Google Home?

8m Al Roberts
Is Twitter slowly dying?

More News Is Twitter slowly dying?

9m Al Roberts
FedEx launches fulfillment service to take on Amazon

Ecommerce FedEx launches fulfillment service to take on Amazon

9m Al Roberts
Target is the top retail digital marketer, so why is it struggling?

Ecommerce Target is the top retail digital marketer, so why is it struggling?

8m Al Roberts
YouTube is "on pace to eclipse TV" thanks to savvy algorithm use

More News YouTube is "on pace to eclipse TV" thanks to savvy algorithm use

9m Al Roberts
YouTube is getting rid of 30-second unskippable pre-roll ads

Ad Industry Metrics YouTube is getting rid of 30-second unskippable pre-roll ads

9m Al Roberts