Digital MarketingDisplay AdvertisingEarly Tests Show Flaws in Facebook Zip Code Targeting

Early Tests Show Flaws in Facebook Zip Code Targeting

Some Zip code segments don't match to Census data, according to analysis presented at SES.

San Francisco– Facebook’s debut of Zip code targeting last week was met with general applause, but early analysis suggests it can’t be trusted for accuracy. At least not yet.

During a session at SES San Francisco this week, XA.net CEO Rob Leathern presented data from Facebook ad testing system optim.al that hinted at accuracy problems for Zip code-based ad targeting. Specifically, Facebook’s estimated addressable audience in several Zip codes in Fremont, CA and Pleasanton, CA did not match to census data for those places.

In the case of at least one Zip code (94566), Facebook’s user estimates are grossly inflated compared to the U.S. Census count. Facebook pegs its audience at 808,000 for that Pleasanton postal zone, whereas census data puts it at 41,000.

facebook-zipcode

In an email exchange after the panel, Leathern noted the problem is not exclusive to Facebook and said he is optimistic about the eventual accuracy of geotargeting on the site.

“Zip code targeting based on IP has historically been less than 50 percent accurate in display advertising, and Facebook is not much different (yet),” he said. “Facebook does have the advantage of a lot of user-supplied location data as well, and we’re pretty confident from talking to them that they’re in the process of figuring it out and improving the targeting capabilities for advertisers.”

He added the failure is not Facebook’s directly, but that of the geographic and IP data that inform its estimates.

Leathern was not the only speaker at this event to suggest flaws in Facebook’s Zip code targeting. “Zip code targeting doesn’t look like it works that well,” said Marty Weintraub, founder of aimClear, an online marketing agency.

Before the introduction of Zip code targeting late last week, advertisers could target geographically only to cities, states, and provinces. They can now deliver individual ads to as many as 2,500 Zip codes.

Related Articles

Chase CMO Kristin Lemkau and the evolution of the ad unit

Display Advertising Chase CMO Kristin Lemkau and the evolution of the ad unit

7m Mike O'Brien
Are we about to enter an era of ad transparency?

Display Advertising Are we about to enter an era of ad transparency?

10m Al Roberts
A guide to five Facebook ad types that will reach your marketing objectives

Display Advertising A guide to five Facebook ad types that will reach your marketing objectives

1y Tereza Litsa
How to use Facebook mobile ads as an "interest indicator" to drive conversions

Display Advertising How to use Facebook mobile ads as an "interest indicator" to drive conversions

1y Sana Ansari
Facebook Advanced Measurement will let advertisers compare Facebook ad performance

Display Advertising Facebook Advanced Measurement will let advertisers compare Facebook ad performance

2y Al Roberts
Ad blocker use continues to grow rapidly

Ad Industry Metrics Ad blocker use continues to grow rapidly

2y Al Roberts
More brands sign up for Snapchat, but many aren't active

Display Advertising More brands sign up for Snapchat, but many aren't active

2y Al Roberts
Facebook to get mid-roll video ads, share revenue with users: report

Display Advertising Facebook to get mid-roll video ads, share revenue with users: report

2y Al Roberts