L90, 24/7 Media Unit Separately Sue DoubleClick

It's the new trend; when advertising giant DoubleClick Inc. sues your companyalleging patent infringement, just sue back.

It’s the new trend; when advertising giant DoubleClick Inc. sues your company alleging patent infringement, just sue back.

That’s the tack rival L90 took this week, following the lead of 24/7 Media (NASDAQ:TFSM). 24/7 Media filed suit against DoubleClick (NASDAQ:DCLK) March 5, alleging that DoubleClick infringed on 24/7 Media’s ad serving patent, then followed up on Thursday with another suit by its subsidiary, Sabela Media. DoubleClick had filed suit against Sabela back in December.

All of this legal business stems from disputes over whose online ad serving patent reigns supreme.

The way these suits are resolved will likely impact how patent disputes among Internet companies are handled in the future. The U.S. Patent Office has come under fire lately, with critics charging that the office is granting patents without understanding the underlying technology, and granting patents for technologies and methods already in common usage.

The L90 suit, filed in Federal District Court for the Southern District of New York, alleges that DoubleClick fraudulently obtained the patent for its ad serving system.

“There were a number of companies serving ads before DoubleClick filed their patent application,” said John Bohnan, president and chief executive officer of L90.

“We still feel extremely confident that these prior art examples invalidate their patent. Moreover, as we set forth in our lawsuit, we believe that DoubleClick has intentionally and willfully engaged in unfair business practices, and as a result we will be seeking damages well into nine figures.”

Not surprisingly, DoubleClick intends to fight the lawsuits.

“L90’s counterclaims are desperate, baseless and clearly retaliatory,” said Elizabeth Wang, vice president and general counsel, DoubleClick.

“This suit is clearly in response to our suit against L90 for infringement of our patent.”

The L90 lawsuit alleges unfair business practices, including DoubleClick’s obtaining of its patent — number 5,948,061 — for a “method for delivery, targeting and measuring advertising over networks.”

The suit filed Thursday by 24/7 Media subsidiary Sabela Media follows on L90’s coattails, alleging that DoubleClick violated federal antitrust laws by failing to give the United States Patent Office important information when it applied for its patent. And Sabela further says that DoubleClick’s suit against it was an anti-competitive move.

“We expect to prove that DoubleClick withheld critical information from the United States Patent Office, knew that its patent was invalid at the time it brought suit against Sabela, and used its patent in an anti-competitive manner, to the detriment of competition on the Internet,” said James Green, co-founder of Sabela Media and president of technology solutions for 24/7 Media.

L90 wants a judge to declare that DoubleClick’s patent is invalid and unenforceable. And it wants the Court to enjoin DoubleClick from its allegedly unlawful conduct, and award L90 monetary and punitive damages.

24/7 Media is asking the Court to bar DoubleClick from further anti-competitive conduct, and is also seeking monetary damages, including punitive damages.

DoubleClick’s suit against L90, filed in November 1999, alleges the company is infringing, inducing and contributing to the infringement of its patent through third parties. Its suit against Sabela Media, filed in December, covers similar legal territory.

Subscribe to get your daily business insights

Whitepapers

US Mobile Streaming Behavior
Whitepaper | Mobile

US Mobile Streaming Behavior

5y

US Mobile Streaming Behavior

Streaming has become a staple of US media-viewing habits. Streaming video, however, still comes with a variety of pesky frustrations that viewers are ...

View resource
Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics for Media Groups
Whitepaper | Analyzing Customer Data

Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics for Media Groups

5y

Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics f...

Data is the lifeblood of so many companies today. You need more of it, all of which at higher quality, and all the meanwhile being compliant with data...

View resource
Learning to win the talent war: how digital marketing can develop its people
Whitepaper | Digital Marketing

Learning to win the talent war: how digital marketing can develop its peopl...

2y

Learning to win the talent war: how digital market...

This report documents the findings of a Fireside chat held by ClickZ in the first quarter of 2022. It provides expert insight on how companies can ret...

View resource
Engagement To Empowerment - Winning in Today's Experience Economy
Report | Digital Transformation

Engagement To Empowerment - Winning in Today's Experience Economy

1m

Engagement To Empowerment - Winning in Today's Exp...

Customers decide fast, influenced by only 2.5 touchpoints – globally! Make sure your brand shines in those critical moments. Read More...

View resource