Lawyers Giving Up on Web Trademark Infringement

Many corporate attorneys have given up on enforcing even a fraction of the infringement they encounter online.

Online trademark and copyright infringement is a more baffling problem than ever for corporate attorneys, who increasingly seem like cornered animals. Fangs were out and hackles up yesterday at the Association of National Advertiser’s Law and Business Affairs conference in New York, where the loss of control over trademarks was the second hottest topic, right after marketer culpability for the childhood obesity epidemic.

Limited Brands SVP and Associate General Counsel Carol Matorin, who represents Victoria’s Secret among other brands, summed up the Sisyphean challenge of policing trademark violations in the midst of what she called “a great ocean of infringing materials.”

“It’s like trying to empty the ocean with a pail,” she said on a panel discussing the topic. “Can you even identify the perpetrator or whoever you’re trying to go after? There’s always been too much to go after in its entirety.” And each day brings more infringement than the last.

Of course, there’s good infringement and bad infringement, and lawyers more than ever must pick their battles. Try to go after every violation, they say, and you’ll burn through your budget in minutes flat. Besides, said Matorin, “If this makes my marketing people happy and is in effect free advertising, why would I waste a moment’s worry?”

Policing MySpace and YouTube is crucial in any case, according to James Perry, VP and associate general counsel for Elizabeth Arden. “There are way too many people in our demographic who are there. It’s the new TV,” he said. “The question is how do we go about doing some broad brushstroke protection?”

He argued the basic questions trademark owners must ask are, “How much [infringement] can you take before you have to do something? And then, what do you want to do?” And he sounded an additional cautionary note to lawyers preparing to sue: “The first step is to make sure it’s not your people doing it, which I found out the hard way is sometimes the case.”

On the topic of fair use and trademark dilution, lawyers say precedents have already been set allowing a broad interpretation of fair use. “Trademark dilution is death by a thousand cuts,” said Joe Dreitler, partner at Frost Brown Todd. “And if there are a thousand people doing parodies of Louis Vuitton, at what point [does it occur]?”

Search giant Google is the recurrent demon invoked in most legal discussions involving trademark infringement. AdWords was the original bogeyman, and attorneys have been consistently frustrated by the mostly free pass they believe Google has been handed by U.S. courts allowing the company to sell advertising against trademarked keywords.

Google’s acquisition of YouTube, and its team of lawyers ready to do copyright battle, poses an entirely different set of challenges, and may be the straw that broke the stubborn mule’s back. As Elizabeth Arden’s Perry put it, and several others echoed, “I think we should disabuse ourselves of the notion we’re going to control content on the Internet.”

Subscribe to get your daily business insights

Whitepapers

US Mobile Streaming Behavior
Whitepaper | Mobile

US Mobile Streaming Behavior

5y

US Mobile Streaming Behavior

Streaming has become a staple of US media-viewing habits. Streaming video, however, still comes with a variety of pesky frustrations that viewers are ...

View resource
Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics for Media Groups
Whitepaper | Analyzing Customer Data

Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics for Media Groups

5y

Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics f...

Data is the lifeblood of so many companies today. You need more of it, all of which at higher quality, and all the meanwhile being compliant with data...

View resource
Learning to win the talent war: how digital marketing can develop its people
Whitepaper | Digital Marketing

Learning to win the talent war: how digital marketing can develop its peopl...

2y

Learning to win the talent war: how digital market...

This report documents the findings of a Fireside chat held by ClickZ in the first quarter of 2022. It provides expert insight on how companies can ret...

View resource
Engagement To Empowerment - Winning in Today's Experience Economy
Report | Digital Transformation

Engagement To Empowerment - Winning in Today's Experience Economy

1m

Engagement To Empowerment - Winning in Today's Exp...

Customers decide fast, influenced by only 2.5 touchpoints – globally! Make sure your brand shines in those critical moments. Read More...

View resource