SocialSocial MediaMarketers Warn Against Facebook Fatigue

Marketers Warn Against Facebook Fatigue

At Social Media Week, JWT execs say hyper personalization and other factors could work against brands and social networks alike.

eastman-jwt-social-weekOn the opening day of Social Media Week in New York City, JWT executives warned of “Facebook fatigue” and other factors that could hurt both brands and social networks alike.

Ann Mack, director of JWT’s Trendspotting practice, described a scenario that may occur when the social network becomes publicly traded and is under pressure to increase revenues. One way it can grow, she said, is to turn its customers’ data into cash. “That will inevitably raise privacy concerns,” potentially prompting people to leave or cut back on using Facebook.

JWT North America CEO David Eastman said some marketers are failing to develop creative approaches for connecting with consumers on Facebook.

Facebook “has become the default tool for lazy marketers who really don’t know what to do,” he said, recalling the days when businesses bought IBM computers because they were a safe bet. “No one got fired for buying IBM. Today’s equivalent is no one gets fired for marketing on Facebook,” he said.

As a result, some brands are pursuing “me-too marketing” on Facebook instead of developing marketing strategies. He pointed to a Business Insider article headlined, “P&G To Lay Off 1,600 After Discovering It’s Free To Advertise On Facebook,” as an example of a brand potentially using Facebook as a “default” marketing strategy.

“Brands need to have conversations with people. Ultimately it doesn’t matter where you are having these conversations,” he said. However, these conversations must not be boring, or else they will turn off consumers.

Eastman also warned that interactions on social networks have their limitations. Case in point: “Likes” on Facebooks or “pins” on Pinterest, a social network that allows users to create a virtual pinboard showcasing images of items they find or like online.

“Pinterest – it’s a beautifully laid out visualization of all the stuff we like, but am I the only person who feels there’s something human missing here?” Eastman said. “It all feels a bit empty.” The problem with Piniterest or Facebook, he said, is that you can ‘like’ or ‘pin’ everything with the same casual action. So if a person ‘pins’ a recipe for a lemon meringue pie, an image of Revlon lipstick, and photos of a newborn and a tank in front of Tiananmen Square [on Pinterest], it’s difficult to determine if a person feels differently about each item,” he said.

Brands must also ensure consumers aren’t bored by “hyper personalization” and hyper targeting, he said. “As hyper personalization makes niche content experiences ever narrower, brands will place greater emphasis on reintroducing randomness, discovery, inspiration, and different points of view to engage us,” he predicted.

Despite the warnings, Eastman had praise for Facebook, along with Amazon, Apple, and Google. “Today’s heros are geeks, not Gordon Gekkos,” he said, suggesting that the executives behind these companies wield more influence and importance that Wall Street wizards or media titans from the 20th century.

The discussion at JWT is one of 350 events planned this week in New York City and 1,200 worldwide as part of Social Media Week.

Whitepaper

US Mobile Streaming Behavior

Whitepaper | Mobile US Mobile Streaming Behavior

4w
Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics for Media Groups

Whitepaper | Actionable Analysis Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics for Media Groups

4w
Giving a Voice to Your Brand

Whitepaper | AI Giving a Voice to Your Brand

4w
Mobile Messaging Masters

Whitepaper | Mobile Mobile Messaging Masters

1m

Related Articles

Why marketers need to reevaluate their Facebook strategies

Social Media Why marketers need to reevaluate their Facebook strategies

9m Vijay Sundaram, CSO, Zoho
How can I tell if my social media strategy is generating results?

Social Media How can I tell if my social media strategy is generating results?

1y Tereza Litsa
Seeing the trees for the forest with paid social

Social & Community Seeing the trees for the forest with paid social

2y Mike O'Brien
A guide to five Facebook ad types that will reach your marketing objectives

Display Advertising A guide to five Facebook ad types that will reach your marketing objectives

2y Tereza Litsa
How to use Facebook Insights to track the success of your social strategy

Analytics How to use Facebook Insights to track the success of your social strategy

2y Tereza Litsa
Facebook goes after clickbait headlines - five tips to maintain reach

Content Marketing Facebook goes after clickbait headlines - five tips to maintain reach

2y Tereza Litsa
The best Facebook marketing strategies for 2017

Social The best Facebook marketing strategies for 2017

2y Tereza Litsa
How to use Facebook mobile ads as an "interest indicator" to drive conversions

Display Advertising How to use Facebook mobile ads as an "interest indicator" to drive conversions

2y Sana Ansari