Last time, I talked about e-mail complaints your company receives from subscribers. These complaints come from people who, instead of simply unsubscribing, take the time to write to you and tell you why your e-mail is missing the mark.
This week, I’ll talk about the other kind of complaint your company is likely to get about its e-mail: recipient complaints sent through ISPs. These complaints are more damaging, because they’re a result of people pushing the spam button on their mail interfaces. Having a high complaint rate in this context doesn’t just mean unhappy users but also unhappy ISPs, which will be more than happy to block your e-mail from getting through at all.
Certainly if you send spam, you deserve this complaint rate. But if you have an opt-in mailing list and send regular marketing e-mail that’s within all compliance rules, you aren’t a spammer. So why is your ISP complaint rate high?
Push the Button
In their attempt to thwart spammers, mail front ends like MSN, AOL, and Google have caused an unwanted side effect. They’ve created a spam button that results in the user no longer receiving e-mail from that sender. To an end user, this has the same result as unsubscribing from the newsletter. Plus, it’s easier. It’s one click versus a longer unsubscribe process, which is different for every publisher. Users are being trained to stop getting e-mail by clicking that button.
Unfortunately, when users click the spam button, they are unfairly marking legitimate e-mail as spam. Instead, they should either unsubscribe or (better) change their preferences on your site or tell you why they don’t like your e-mail anymore.
In addition to a spam button in the user interfaces, mail programs should also offer “unsubscribe” and “send feedback about this e-mail” buttons. This would require a standardized unsubscribe process and a standard feedback e-mail address that can be placed in e-mail headers.
Ben Isaacson, privacy and compliance leader for CheetahMail, has done a lot of work in this area. Isaacson brought this user interface issue up and sparked the idea for this column. “Similar to Web site user-generated feedback, e-mail recipient feedback has become a critical component of every e-mailer’s behavioral measurement efforts (albeit, a negative component),” says Isaacson. “Every e-mailer should be tracking these key components from complaints; how they subscribed, recent behavioral activity, demographic profile, and type of content sent. While efforts such as MSN/Hotmail’s effort to separate off an ‘unsubscribe’ button are commendable, it is still incumbent on e-mailers to mitigate both complaints and unsubscribes by better tailoring their e-mail programs to their recipient’s preferences.”
By providing easy one-click options to subscribers beyond simply marking something as spam, we encourage users to communicate with us directly or unsubscribe instead of calling our e-mail spam.
What Can You Do Now?
Users will always take the path of least resistance, especially if the outcome is perceived to be the same. What can you do in the meantime?
Until these additional buttons become part of major mail programs’ user interfaces, do this yourself in your e-mail templates. Make the “unsubscribe” and “feedback” buttons prominent. Tell people that instead of marking the e-mail as spam, they can easily change their subscription status if they no longer want your e-mail. This information is usually buried in a footer in tiny print, so of course people choose the spam button. Encourage feedback, and make sure your e-mail is relevant and timely and meets users’ expectations.
Once these mechanisms are in place, both of your complaint rates (from users and from ISPs) should go down.
Thoughts, questions, comments? Let me know.
Until next time…
Social media has developed into an effective component of digital strategy, but measuring its performance is still a challenge. How will analytics affect social media in 2017?
A great customer experience has moved from ‘nice to have’ to ‘can’t do without’. Your users expect be engaged from the moment they land on your site, held in rapture at each stage of the conversion funnel. Is your CMS the key to delivering?
With the majority of web activity now occurring on mobile devices, knowing how well a brand performs on mobile is critical.
Mobile has become a powerful force in the marketing world, forcing retailers to adapt fast. This article explores the benefits of mobile web versus mobile apps in terms of investment, engagement and conversion.