John Donne said, “No man is an island.” In marketing, no medium should be an island. All too often, though, media are treated as individual silos, with little or no coordination between interactive and traditional efforts. The result for customers is often confusion and inconsistent messaging.
Each marketing medium has its own strengths. Utilizing those strengths in concert can enhance a campaign’s overall effectiveness.
Some of e-mail’s key strengths can support traditional direct marketing:
- Precision. Sophisticated segmentation and personalization enable true one-to-one messaging.
- Immediacy. Most recipients will receive the message within hours of it being sent.
- Cost effectiveness. E-mail can touch more people more frequently at a lower cost.
- Responsiveness. Purchase can be just a click away.
With the holiday season fast approaching, here are some examples of integrating traditional and e-mail marketing in holiday sales campaigns.
If you send holiday catalogs or brochures through traditional mail, they probably account for a significant percentage of your annual marketing budget. Inevitably, though, some will be recycled or discarded without a glance.
Schedule an e-mail message to arrive just before the first in-home date, alerting people to the catalog’s imminent arrival. They’ll look for it, heightening awareness and anticipation. Customize the message with highlighted items, offers, and promotions that may be of particular interest to recipients.
We’ve all received offers, coupons, and promotions we intend to take advantage of. But then they expire before we can.
Schedule an e-mail soon after the last in-home date or shortly before expiration to encourage people to follow through on their good intentions. If online ordering or purchasing is available, enable the same offer on your e-commerce Web site. Including a link in the e-mail encourages conversion to a sale.
Maximizing ROI (define) by balancing the number of recipients and cost per piece is a well-established practice in traditional direct marketing. Integrating e-mail adds another dimension to the mix.
Widen a campaign to a larger number of recipients using e-mail’s cost-effectiveness and precision. Increase focus on key segments by combining print only, e-mail only, and print plus e-mail to further heighten campaign effectiveness.
When running multiphase campaigns, enable crossover between media. Make use of user preferences. For instance, ask people which medium they prefer. Apply business rules based on behavior and implied preferences. If an e-mail address starts bouncing, switch that person to print. If she doesn’t respond to print, send her e-mail.
Use e-mail to rapidly and cost-effectively test different offers and promotions. Then, select the best for your print campaign. One caveat: switching to another medium introduces a second variable, which can throw off test results. To minimize this outcome, use this technique for factors that are less affected by presentation. Pretest to identify and account for variances between print and e-mail responsiveness.
Media integration requires the interactive and direct marketing groups work closely together; this may mean cultural or managerial changes. What is acceptable and effective varies from medium to medium. The groups must respect each other’s expertise. Evaluating success requires campaigns to be analyzed holistically. An e-mail supporting a catalog may not meet your standard response requirements on its own, but its effect on catalog sales may be significant. Similarly, a postcard to a person whose e-mail is bouncing may not produce the direct marketing return on investment normally required.
As you plan and prepare your holiday campaigns, look for opportunities to integrate your media. Play to the strengths of each, and respond to recipients’ preferences (both explicit and implied) to enhance the customer experience and maximize your overall ROI.
Until next time.
Want more e-mail marketing information? ClickZ E-Mail Reference is an archive of all our e-mail columns, organized by topic.
Vote for your favorite product or campaign for the 2006 ClickZ Marketing Excellence Awards, October 30 through close of business (5 pm EST) on November 8. Winners will be announced on November 13.
Derek is off this week. Today’s column ran earlier on ClickZ.
Do you ever get the feeling that you’re being ignored? That despite your best efforts to ensure every email you write is a) highly relevant; b) succinct; and c) blurb-free, your message still gets overlooked?
As consumers, we live in a real-time world. We have the technology to access the information we need, when and where we want it, and the "when" is usually "now."
A new starter in Team SaleCycle recently asked me the following question… “Wouldn't they just come back anyway?”