SocialSocial CommerceNutella Says Facebook Ads Outperformed TV

Nutella Says Facebook Ads Outperformed TV

Brand incorporates social ads into traditional marketing mix model for campaign in Germany.

nutella-deutschlandNutella is employing the decades-old marketing mix model (MMM) – a nuanced sales attribution system for integrated campaigns – to measure the effectiveness of Facebook ads. For instance, the company, which sells chocolate hazelnut spread, combined Facebook ads with TV spots and other paid channels in Germany during December 2011, attributing 15 percent of sales from the yuletide campaign to its Facebook ads. In terms of return on investment, the brand told ClickZ that Facebook ads outperformed the TV spend, according to its MMM data.

Online measurement has long been a hot topic among marketers. Over the years, brands have often determined campaign spend for individual media ingredients (e.g., TV, radio, magazine, coupons, display ads, etc.) by using a marketing mix model system – or a similar sales attribution program referred to by a different name.

Kevin Lee is an executive chairman with marketing services firm Didit and a ClickZ columnist. He said brands that plug Facebook ads into their MMMs show they’ve started considering the social site to be more of a bonafide channel, rather than experimental.

“Once Facebook ads spend becomes material, it belongs in the [MMM],” Lee said. “If you are only dabbling, it’s going to be too difficult to understand the impact of your Facebook advertising.”

John Donahue is director of business strategy and consumer engagement at content and technology firm Socialistic. He’s also served as an analytics exec for Omnicom Media Group as well as CTO at BuzzLogic (now Twelvefold Media). Donahue said he “applauded” Nutella for incorporating Facebook into the marketing mix model, stating the methodology’s results gives brands a sense of ROI.

“At the end of the day, [Facebook is] a predictable audience that you can message and get reliable reach/results,” Donahue said.

Campaign Reaches 30 Percent of Online Germans

For the holidays, Ferrero, Nutella’s parent company, sought to increase awareness and sales from Dec. 1 through Dec. 24, 2011. Ferrero wouldn’t give specifics about the broadcast campaign but says the Facebook ads got the largest return on investment when compared to the other media channels.

nutella-2Nutella bought Facebook’s Reach Block ads, which are designed to create a predetermined number of impressions within a demographic, and Premium Ads in the effort. Five different versions of the Facebook ads were used. The creative encouraged people to become fans/likes of the Nutella Deutschland page and to try out its “Advent Calendar” app, where they could open calendar doors in the German Christmas tradition. The social promos reached 30 percent of the online population in the country, equaling 3.8 million unique impressions, according to Gfk Group, a Germany-based online consumer panel provider.

Angela Kim, a new media manager for the Italy-based Ferrero, said in a statement, “As well as proven incremental reach and a positive cross-media effect between TV and Facebook, we demonstrated that Facebook lifts sales for [CPG brands] in bricks and mortar stores.”

This story was originally published on May 4, 2012, and comes in at No. 4 on our countdown of the 10 most popular ClickZ news stories of 2012. As ClickZ looks back over the past year, we’re celebrating the best of 2012, as determined by our readers. Enjoy!

Related Articles

Facebook targets eBay, Craigslist with Marketplace but falls way short

Ecommerce Facebook targets eBay, Craigslist with Marketplace but falls way short

2y Al Roberts
Social media marketing spend has surged over the years, but falls short of estimates

CPG Social media marketing spend has surged over the years, but falls short of estimates

2y Al Roberts
Behavioral targeting is coming to Snapchat

CPG Behavioral targeting is coming to Snapchat

2y Al Roberts
Three exceptional examples of local social media campaigns

Local Three exceptional examples of local social media campaigns

2y Harsh Agrawal
American Apparel: driving customer centricity in an omnichannel world

Analytics American Apparel: driving customer centricity in an omnichannel world

2y Sophie Loras
How to manage Facebook pages for a multi-location business

Local How to manage Facebook pages for a multi-location business

2y Tereza Litsa
How brands in Hong Kong are cashing in on Pokémon GO

Asia How brands in Hong Kong are cashing in on Pokémon GO

2y Sophie Loras
Verizon acquires Yahoo's operating business for $4.8 billion

Agency Spotlight Verizon acquires Yahoo's operating business for $4.8 billion

2y Sophie Loras