Digital MarketingDisplay AdvertisingSophisticated Cyber Criminals Cost Brands Billions

Sophisticated Cyber Criminals Cost Brands Billions

During an Ad Week presentation last week, Michael Tiffany, chief executive of White Ops, explained ad fraud and the bots that make it possible.

Advertising fraud is a lot like the arcade game Whac-A-Mole: every time you knock it out, it just resurfaces somewhere else, said Michael Tiffany, self-described gentleman hacker and chief executive (CEO) of digital security solution White Ops, at an Ad Week presentation entitled “Ad Fraud: The Dark Side of Advertising.”

Hacking into a customer’s account is infinitely easier than robbing a bank, but now that banks are catching onto the cyber criminals, many of them have begun to attack advertising agencies. And they are causing a ton of damage.

Ad fraud costs brands $6 billion in fake impressions each year. At its center are bots, software designed to carry out automated tasks, typically simple and repetitive, on the Internet, such as Web searches and answering questions on help channels. They can also wiggle mice, put items in shopping carts, and click on links.

“If you want to sell retargeted inventory on a cost-per-action basis, what is your best strategy, to show real ads? Or ads at a lower rate to robots that are clones of large numbers of consumers?” Tiffany asked, adding that the latter can target 10 times as many people for a twentieth of the price, and the same amount of effort is required to put out 1 million fake impressions as 100 million.

“The bot traffic gets laundered through the advertising ecosystem through a series of middlemen,” Tiffany explained. “Everyone who thinks they’re avoiding the problem isn’t, because metrics in this industry are gameable.”

What makes bots, which can be programmed to only work when a real person is online, most difficult to get around is that analytics implicitly trust the machines with which they interact. “Bot nets are made for real computers where people really buy things,” Tiffany said. “No one can differentiate between Bob Smith and Bot Smith on the same cookie.”

Ad fraud is most common on websites with the lowest and highest cost-per-mille, which are the least monitored and most lucrative, respectively.

“There’s a huge incentive mismatch. The bad guys, when they win, make millions of dollars. When the good guys win, we get to keep our jobs for another day,” Tiffany said.

Because cyber criminals are extremely savvy, stamping out their handiwork is complicated and requires sophisticated counterhacking. There may be some good news on the horizon, though, as the frequency of fraud was down in August, when White Ops publicly stated it would be keeping an eye on premium ad buying for an Association of National Advertisers (ANA) study.

“Start with easy actions that don’t require technical engineering,” Tiffany advised. “They just require putting some eyes on the problem.”

Image via Shutterstock.

Related Articles

Chase CMO Kristin Lemkau and the evolution of the ad unit

Display Advertising Chase CMO Kristin Lemkau and the evolution of the ad unit

5m Mike O'Brien
Are we about to enter an era of ad transparency?

Display Advertising Are we about to enter an era of ad transparency?

8m Al Roberts
Seven ways advertisers can deal with brand safety concerns

Actionable Analysis Seven ways advertisers can deal with brand safety concerns

1y Al Roberts
How deep learning is changing the game for both advertisers and consumers

Data-Driven Marketing How deep learning is changing the game for both advertisers and consumers

1y Daniel Surmacz
Facebook Advanced Measurement will let advertisers compare Facebook ad performance

Display Advertising Facebook Advanced Measurement will let advertisers compare Facebook ad performance

1y Al Roberts
Ads are now a billion-dollar business for Amazon

Display Advertising Ads are now a billion-dollar business for Amazon

1y Al Roberts
Why brands should care about brand safety in mobile advertising

Display Advertising Why brands should care about brand safety in mobile advertising

2y Andy Favell
Mobile ad viewability: what is it and does it matter?

Display Advertising Mobile ad viewability: what is it and does it matter?

2y Andy Favell