Is Kim Kardashian’s #CorrectiveAd Aligned with MRC’s New Social Media Guidelines?
The Media Rating Council’s newly-released guidelines require that sponsored user-generated content (UGC) appearing on a social media platform should be clearly labeled to distinguish between what is paid advertising and what is organic. And paid UGC should not be counted in reported measurement.
The Media Rating Council (MRC) unveiled its Social Media Measurement Guidelinesyesterday to establish a detailed set of methods and common practices for organizations that measure social media activity.
The preliminary guidelines, which further the requirement of clearly labeling paid user-generated content (UGC), say that paid UGC that is valid but should be disclosed and segregated in reporting from activity associated with branded content. In addition, paid UGC should not be counted in reported measurement, according to the guidelines.
Although the guidelines aim to further the concept of clearly labeling, they don’t specify what type of paid UGC is “properly disclosed” or “clearly labeled.” For example, is the #CorrectiveAd drug post below from Kim Kardashian aligned with the new guidelines?
A photo posted by Kim Kardashian West (@kimkardashian) on
Ron Pinelli Jr., vice president of digital research and standards at the MRC, doesn’t provide a “yes or no” answer, explaining that the concept of clearly labeling gets complex depending on the source of the original authorship.
“The Social Media Measurement Guidelines further [the concept of clearly labeling] by encouraging clear labeling of sponsored or paid UGC, but this might not always occur. Measurers seeking to comply with the guidelines should develop mechanisms to track and report sponsored or paid UGC separately from organic content to the extent possible.” he says. “Furthermore, if such activity is intended to be invalid [this is not the case in Kim Kardashian’s post above] for the sake of inflating measurement, referred to as ‘shilling’ in the document, measurers should develop techniques to detect and remove such activity.”
Noah Mallin, head of social at agency MEC’s North America operations, doesn’t give a definitive answer either, though he notes that there’s a whole other level of compliance that is necessary with highly regulated industries. Particularly with the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the guidelines can be restrictive and tricky.
“Labeling is an open industry issue. Our point of view has always been that if a celebrity is compensated on behalf of a brand to post something, the post has to disclose such relationship,” he says. “For example, the celebrity can use a hashtag #endorsement or write a description like ‘the company I work with…’ I think a basic question we can ask is, would users understand that the person who is sharing product information has the relationship with the company that owns the product?”
As an advertiser, Mallin thinks that it’s challenging to have a consistent measurement across different social media platforms, but he believes that the release of the guidelines is a good sign.
“Social is made of different networks that have their own way of measuring, so I think setting up an industry standard is good first step. It definitely helps demystify social for our clients,” he says.
The guidelines are available for public comment until October 15. After that, the working group – which includes American Association of Advertising Agencies (4A’s), the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) and the Word of Mouth Marketing Association – will address comments and issue a final version.
Streaming has become a staple of US media-viewing habits. Streaming video, however, still comes with a variety of pesky frustrations that viewers are ...
Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics for Media Groups
5y
Winning the Data Game: Digital Analytics Tactics f...
Data is the lifeblood of so many companies today. You need more of it, all of which at higher quality, and all the meanwhile being compliant with data...
Learning to win the talent war: how digital marketing can develop its peopl...
2y
Learning to win the talent war: how digital market...
This report documents the findings of a Fireside chat held by ClickZ in the first quarter of 2022. It provides expert insight on how companies can ret...
How Meta lay-offs will impact social media marketing in 2023
1y
Ed East
How Meta lay-offs will impact social media marketi...
Advertisers and brands will need to be patient with the metaverse. Brands may need to redirect or pause 2023 ad spend in the platform until it has bee...
Turning TikToks into book sales: Penguin Random House's influencer marketin...
2y
Benjamin Broomfield
Turning TikToks into book sales: Penguin Random Ho...
When you imagine the sort of companies who are successfully taking to TikTok, one that sits in a 600-year-old industry such as publishing might not sp...
As the world is getting more and more polarized, brands are struggling to find ways to stay relevant and avoid being affected by the cancel culture Re...
45% of retailers plan to spend more on social media advertising in 2021 vs ...
3y
Idris Nagri
45% of retailers plan to spend more on social medi...
The 2021 Global Social Advertising Trends report includes new stats and trends on retail social media advertising compiled from a poll of 300 global r...
Survey: Social media, marketing and the impact of the news
3y
Michael McCaw
Survey: Social media, marketing and the impact of ...
As governments and social media platforms lock horns on news placements, we’re asking marketers for their opinion on how the issue will shape their st...
The role of AI & social media marketers in a B2B marketing campaign
3y
Amanda Jerelyn
The role of AI & social media marketers in a B2B m...
A B2B marketing campaign in recent times is more capable of driving sales. We look at how AI and social media marketers together can enhance any B2B m...