Digital advertising, both on the Internet and in traditional media, isn’t scaling. The buy and sell sides (advertisers and publishers) have neglected to get their platforms right in the advertising industry. If we don’t work this out in the next year or so, we could have big problems.
I have nothing against the outsourced ad operation industry per se, but it only exists because of a huge failing among tool vendors on both sides of the fence. There should be no reason for the vast number of agency or publisher staffers required to handle ad operations. There should be significantly more process automation and many fewer bodies to get the job done.
Companies like Operative and Ad Operations Interactive exist because ad platforms don’t automate everything they can. The bigger outsourced operation companies have built tools and technology that streamline the ad operation process, or they use cheap labor and extensive processes to ensure no mistakes are made.
Is it a coincidence that many tool vendors have their own outsourced ad operation teams? It shouldn’t be lost on anyone that outsourced ad operations can be a big revenue generator — and that it may not be in vendors’ best interest to completely automate these solutions.
On the agency side, pressure was never put on tool vendors to streamline and automate the tools because of billing methods. Agencies typically bill out for ad operations on an hourly rate This helped interactive departments become profit centers. They didn’t mind throwing bodies at the problem, so long as advertisers were willing to pay the bills.
Things are changing fast. Digital advertising is growing quickly. A problem that could be handled by humans is now overwhelmed by volume. This is the dark side of online advertising success. And it will kill the industry.
Online advertising can’t handle another few billion dollars of volume with the tools in place today. In my column about this in June 2005, I wrote:
So this column is a call to the technology providers to take their cues from the upshift in the current market landscape. Technologies languished during the past few years of market downturn. Most, frankly, are sorry shadows of the promise we saw back in 2000. The core technologies we built to serve ads, plan and manage campaigns, handle sales, implement insertion orders, and, perhaps most important, report results have been underfunded long enough. The industry must begin to focus on these platforms with an eye to the media future. It must create technologies to easily handle the transition to nonlinear video (and audio) ad insertion and become ready to handle the media shift.
It’s been over a year, and nobody’s stepped up to the plate. What’s happening? Huge ad operation staff attrition at agencies. Increasingly more outsourcing to companies like Operative, which have the processes and workflow automation in place to scale. This problem isn’t just about the current online advertising industry. It’s about scaling the future of advertising across all digital media. We’re not ready.
It’s time to get this fixed. Fast.
New Top-Level Domains (TLDs) have become more popular in the last couple of years, so here’s everything you need to know about them.
Amazon Prime was launched in 2005 as an express shipping membership program and more than a decade later it has tens of millions of subscribers who enjoy a lot more than just free, fast shipping on millions of products Amazon sells.
Sure, some apps are doing personalized push notifications, but what happens when your users are in the app?
Since cloud computing first gained mainstream attention around 2009, its popularity has exploded. Promising increased efficiency, flexibility and cost-effectiveness, it was hailed as the ultimate business solution. But are users seeing the benefits?