• ClickZ
  • Posts
  • The 3 creative paths (and 1 destroys your CAC:LTV)

The 3 creative paths (and 1 destroys your CAC:LTV)

PLUS: Why advertising still matters in a skeptical world

Follow us on LinkedIn 🔗

Hi there!

Highlights from today's newsletter:
🤖 Inside Unilever's AI beauty marketing assembly line
🔄 The missing link in omnichannel that drives real connection
✍️ Good copy doesn't sell—it stings (and sticks)

EDITOR’S PICK

#AI IN SEARCH

Search is no longer Google’s game alone.

Google’s AI Mode—powered by Gemini—now serves answers directly in conversational summaries, cutting clicks to websites by more than half in some cases. Ads are being stitched into these AI responses, and Google’s new AI Max campaigns let the algorithm pick creatives and match intent without keywords, leaving marketers with less control but higher reported performance.

Meanwhile, Meta is testing AI-powered search across Instagram and Facebook, turning its feeds into intent engines, while TikTok is doubling down on search ads that brands say deliver lower CPAs and lift Google search downstream.

Discovery is being rewritten by AI. Brands that adapt early—across Google’s AI Mode and emerging social search—will win the next wave of intent.

*Article published by Search Engine Watch—ClickZ’s sister publication

WHAT WE ARE READING

Advertising remains vital in a world often skeptical of its value, as impactful campaigns like Old Spice's demonstrate that creativity can transcend mere metrics. It matters because it engages consumers at a deeper level, encouraging them to think and feel differently about brands. This relevance persists amidst changing cultural and technological landscapes, requiring brands to adapt and maintain their influence.

Unilever's development of a generative AI system for its digital creative significantly increases production efficiency, generating 400 assets per product instead of 20, while reducing creative production costs. Though it poses potential challenges for creative agencies, marketers benefit from enhanced speed and effectiveness, catalyzing a shift towards hybrid AI approaches.

In times of economic uncertainty, maintaining marketing efforts on Pinterest is crucial for long-term success, as the platform reaches a broad, actively shopping audience.

By leveraging awareness campaigns, performance marketing solutions, and AI-driven tools, marketers can optimize engagement with high-intent shoppers while emphasizing value-based messaging to align with changing consumer budgets.

TOP VOICE

💭Insights from Brett Wagner

Your creative falls into one of these 3 buckets. | Brett Wagner

But one destroys your CAC to LTV...

Path 1: Own your AI narrative

Tell customers "Hey, we used to spend $67,000+ on photo shoots, now we use AI and pass those savings to you. That's why we can offer 13% more off this sale"

I can see more and more brands starting to lean into this direct, honest, value-driven style of owning how they are using AI and making it clear that AI is creating more value for them as a consumer.

Path 2: Go intentionally crude

I'm seeing more and more brands incorporate hand drawn elements where you can immediately tell there was artistry behind it. This is more of an emotional angle as opposed to a value angle. It's like if you look at the last Polaroid campaign, they're trying to fight back vs this tech first era and bring people back to more of that "when times were simpler" energy.

The goal here is to make it so intentionally not AI that no one could interpret it as AI. Even bringing in some of your behind the scenes content to show how your creative was made.

I wouldn't be surprised if "human made" became a proactive badge brands start using the same way that platforms are starting to label AI content.

Path 3: The danger zone

Most B2B brands land in the messy middle

They use AI but try to hide it. They polish AI generated content just enough to look "professional" but not enough to fool anyone.

Consumers have developed a BS radar, and we've seen it time and time again when your marketing feels too much like marketing. It's not gonna hit. The same is true with AI in its current form.

Pick path 1 or 2.

Avoid path 3 at all costs.

Especially in the next six to twelve months.

💭Insights from Kira Klaas

Give us the finger. | Kira Klaas

I’ve been thinking a lot about copywriting recently, for a few reasons, but a big one is that my LinkedIn feed is still covered in Ōura’s “Give us the finger” campaign (which launched way back at the end of May). It’s beautifully art directed, yes, but that tagline steals the show. It introduces a more defiant approach to the wellness space. It taps into a cultural, attitudinal shift around aging. It maintains a clear connection to what the product is (a thing that goes on your finger). It's got spice.

It’s not easy to come across a line that good. When you’re establishing a copywriting style, you’re likely to end up untangling much broader strategic threads. A brand’s voice is inextricably tied up in company positioning; if you’re writing for a web surface, let’s say, there’s the difficult balance of “product” and “brand” messaging to strike; and when you’re rebranding and rethinking your brand’s underlying personality, it’s an exercise in itself to determine which attitudes you want to embody and to what degree.

I’ve said it before, and it’s still a hill I’m willing to die on—copywriting is the most underestimated discipline in brand strategy. I don’t say that to diminish visual identity work whatsoever, but design more often gets the glory. Developing a color palette, typography, imagery—a whole cohesive system—is a huge feat, but if it stays silent, it can’t fully come to life. Too often, in the process of hiring expensive agencies for rebrands and campaign creative and nitpicking design details, copy gets tacked on as an afterthought.

While B2B design has come a long way, the B2B landscape isn’t the most inspiring for voice. We see a lot of blatant copycatting. We see a lot of shortcuts to replace deeper strategic thinking and positioning work, like the dreaded, no good, very bad “all-in-one.” 🔪 Everyone has a best-in-class platform, an innovative solution, and a cheaper, better, easier, or faster way to sell you. It’s corporate Mad Libs that tells audiences little about why they should care.

Most people will agree that the best marketing doesn’t feel like marketing. And you feel like you’re being marketed to when you can’t tell one cold email pitch apart from the other, when you know you’re being sold to, when everything feels transactional. By contrast, the best leaders recognize copywriting’s ultimate role in making an audience feel seen, heard, and recognized. And great copywriting could be selling to you, but it’s so fun, different, or engaging that you don’t even mind!

There are three things the best and most memorable copy does:

1. Good copy taps into what you already believe.
2. Good copy gives your audience agency.
3. Good copy takes advantage of every opportunity.

WHAT WE ARE LISTENING TO

🎙 BEHIND THE NUMBERS

Authenticity is the secret sauce in omnichannel marketing, and it starts with consistent storytelling. When every touchpoint reinforces the same message, trust grows naturally—while mixed signals quickly erode credibility.

Interestingly, physical experiences are making a comeback. 71% of consumers view print as more authentic than digital, a perception that’s even stronger among younger audiences oversaturated with online content. This makes packaging and other tactile elements more than just functional; they become a brand’s handshake, offering a tangible moment of connection.

As consumers increasingly seek interactions that feel both real and immersive, brands that blend physical and digital experiences seamlessly will create deeper loyalty and stand out in an overcrowded market.

Editorial

Contact an editor to create content for your business.


Advertise with us

Connect with us on socials

Reply

or to participate.